The climate change example is bad because oil companies have been actively suppressing correct evidence showing the existence of climate change since the 1980s. I'm less familiar with the tobacco studies, but I wouldn't be surprised if they've been doing the same thing, just on longer time scales.
I’d agree with this but in the real world, we usually don’t and can’t really know if the methodology and statistical analysis was solid and rigorously followed as described in the paper – if it they were even adequately described. The only way to be sure is to replicate the study and that costs time and money (as per Brandolini's Law).
Evaluating incentives (e.g., follow the money) is a useful heuristic to evaluate the creditability and trustworthiness of a particular study.
Sure it’s an ad hominem attack to use past behavior to judge someone’s current or actions statements and taking actions as a result (eg ignoring them). And yet, is that a logical fallacy? I don’t think so but you seem to have an opposite conclusion.
Now, if you're talking about using such criteria as a heuristic to decide which papers to put effort into evaluating, then we have another discussion to have.
0. https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/06/03/repost-epistemic-learn...