The problem is that it introduces all these failure cases.
Pen+Paper's only drawback is that it's said to be slow, in practice it can be finished same-day by booking enough elections volunteers.
> but it is better than having no paper record at all
That's a weird standard. "Sure, it costs a lot and introduces all these weird and nigh-undetectable failure cases but the other machines were even worse! ..."
> the option of a manual recount
Which will be fought, of course. They always are. So in the end only some areas will ever have a human audit.
The public deserves that every vote be hand counted by a bipartisan team.