Ah, but as always, the million dollar question is ..... What does the PagerDuty small print say ?
My guess is the small print is not "bulletproof reliability" or five-nines. I betcha their contract is full of exclusions and get-outs.
It's a bit like the famous Verizon 100% SLA. Any idiot knows its not technically feasible, but the reason you pay the Verizon-tax is so the've got some cash to pay you the inevitable SLA claims.