My problem with using Rust is the way its complexity creeps into everything. There are large numbers of stdlib utility traits whose idiomatic use you have to remember to read almost any real world code. There's hardly a Rust library in common use that isn't a huge sprawling mass of over abstracted generics and macros. Even command line parsing is made to be a vastly complex endeavour. There are admittedly sugary niceties (eg derive attributes) that can make use of many of these libraries tractable for easy cases. But overall any substantial Rust program makes cognitive and memory demands on the programmer far in excess of what most languages require for the equivalent in my experience.
> Even command line parsing is made to be a vastly complex endeavour.
Yes, I even wrote a library for that once but then realized it only complicates everything and adds limitations. Nowadays I just do that by hand. For one it's guaranteed to be shorter than any parsing library, but also it's a good opportunity to think about what kind of arguments I need and in which form. And copy-pasting the parser from the previous project and adapting it is quick & easy.
My beef (such as it is) is that I doubt I will ever get to the level of fluency where I 'just code' with it, rather than intermittent stripes of coding & fuming. It takes me probably 4x as long to do anything compared to any other language I've used (and although I'm not a talented programmer, I am a polyglot).
Oddly on the cli parsing thing, I did end up finding a library I like - bpaf. It's kind of abstract but seems more conceptually principled than the near-universal clap. The kind of abstraction where once you have grasped a small set of orthogonal concepts, you can just combine them at will, seems OK to me. As contrasted with the type which has dozens of small rules, and special cases that rely heavily on (human) memory and/or constant doc lookups.
I know what you mean. I feel much more productive with it nowadays and many things just make sense now, but it took me a long, long time to get to that point. Rust is very much not beginner-friendly, and while I think it was worth it this is why it will never replace certain other languages. I don't mind the compilation speed as much as some people seem to do, but the learning curve definitely is a problem.
However I can imagine when Rust borrowing rules can be a huge pain. This happens when you expect to continue using the same style of programming that relies on big piles of (often cyclic) object graphs built with references/pointers, shared mutability, heavy (runtime) indirection and inheritance. A style that is so prevalent in OOP projects written in Java, JS, Python. I don't like this style at all, and always tried to avoid it even when coding in those languages, because I believe it causes more harm than good. Rust will simply force you to unlearn it. And some people won't need to unlearn much, and some will have to unlearn a lot. Changing habits is always pain.
I think it should be simply considered a different paradigm.
I addressed this above and believe it to be an unconvincing explanation of Rust's difficulty. Many polyglot programmers comfortable with, and experienced in, switching (and learning new) paradigms, still find Rust more difficult than other languages they have learned. In my experience most just give up. I haven't, but neither have I become remotely productive in the language.
Of course my experience is just one person's sample. There isn't much else to go one. But the Rust Foundation clearly agrees with me, given its 2024 roadmap. In our view, Rust is hard to learn and use, more than most languages, and problematically so for many.
Also, there aren't any other mainstream languages with borrow checker at the moment. The problem with Rust is that it introduces many novel ideas, not just some old ideas wrapped in a different syntax (e.g. like Kotlin or Swift). They need time to get into developers heads. Similarly it took many years to accept some ideas from FP into mainstream languages, and people were even debating if Java needed lambdas.
And BTW: I didn't find Rust harder to learn than, e.g. Python or Scala... Scala was kinda fun, but FP required similar amount of mind-bending as lifetimes in Rust, and Python was just purely frustrating.
The difference between what you and I are claiming isn't in the substantive content, it's that you, Shiny Happy Rust Person-style (exemplifying what many of us find so ugly and bullying about the much-vaunted "Rust community") insist on universalising your personal experience.
I've already told you that novelty is nothing whatsoever to do with why I find Rust difficult. It has few novel concepts, and they are simple enough. Note that I never mentioned the fucking borrow checker. Now fuck off. I've blocked you anyway.
Because these two lists are mutually exclusive.
On the survey they ask:
* Do you use X today?
* Do you want to continue to use X in the future?
"Most loved" means "the ratio of yes/yes answers is high", and "most dreaded" means "the ratio of yes/no answers is high."
Rust wins "most loved" because many users say yes/yes, and few say yes/no.
It is very hard if even possible to objectively assess the difficulty of the language, because difficulty is inherently subjective and depends heavily on prior experience. The fact that there are many people who claim to be more productive in Rust than e.g Python or Java, but at the same time many others that don't share that opinion, IMHO supports my claim this is mostly a matter of a paradigm shift.
Also I noticed many developers somehow don't count the difficulty to fix bugs towards the difficulty of the language. And maybe that's also an explanation why we end up with so vastly different opinions.