It links a review of the Moderna paper by Alex Berenson, a popular COVID denialist who has repeatedly made verifiably false claims about the effectiveness of vaccines. Commenters defending the article in the reply are insisting on non-sequitor points like "the COVID vaccine offered no protection" and that there was a "conspiracy" to release it to the public anyway.
Prior to COVID, Berenson acquired notoriety for publishing a book-length polemic claiming marijuana use causes psychosis and violent mental illness, supported by a veritable museum of rhetorical fallacies. It received reviews like the following from Columbia,
>"As scientists with a combined 70-plus years of drug education and research on psychoactive substances, we find Berenson's assertions to be misinformed and reckless."
So anyone familiar with Berenson's reputation would rightfully be skeptical of axe-grinding claims about medicine that are cited only to him. On par to that reputation, Berenson includes essential factual mistakes in his review of the paper, such as referring to death certificates to state that RSV kills approximately 400x less American adults every year than the NFID reports. That kind of mistake is easy to make if you lack essential foundational knowledge about what you are analyzing, and have already settled on the point you want to make before you go looking for evidence.
It would make sense Berneson can't conduct a good analysis of the paper, because he has no formal medical education and his entire "career" commenting on medicine has consisted of peddling conspiracy theories after concluding his work as a novelist.
If you are insisting that post is "substantive," and that it wasn't reasonable for it to be flagged by this community per the community's guidelines, I'd be curious why. This is the current top post of the thread, so maybe you can reply to reintroduce what you feel is a substantive subject of discussion in a less inflammatory, conspiratorial way, and without staking it on an article by someone outside professional medicine containing rudimentary errors.
I turned on showdead and promptly reënabled it. Referencing Covid and mRNA vaccines in response to a non-Covid non-MRNA vaccine seems like using "Hacker News for political or ideological battle" and pursuing "generic tangents" [1].
If you enable it in your profile, dead articles appear, which means
"The post was killed by software, user flags, or moderators."
In this case, a downvoted(?) thread appears at the bottom with 28 replies.
This is supposed to be a data-driven discussion forum - people correctly flagging content you like != censorship.
As pointed out in its replies, the article linked in that comment includes some basic mistakes like attributing to death certificates that RSV kills 35 American adults every year, when NFID claims 14k. Launching a conspiratorial discussion from the platform of an article with such rudimentary errors is always going to result in downvotes on this community, so nothing seems unusual about this instance to me.
And it's not like they linked a review of the paper by any kind of medical doctor. Anyone who recognizes the name Alex Berenson would reasonably assume the article is bogus, especially in the context of infectious diseases. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_Berenson
There's plenty of places online to do whatever you want, people like it here because we at least sort of try to follow some rules to encourage a fragile thing (informed debate).
Like I said, happy to look at data about this, but not random stray stories.
Hard to follow what you're saying. I'm sorry if the italics made it hard for you actually read the content, but what are you trying to say?
To restate my point: I agree that not everyone will agree on content, but there are rules of engagement, and if you don't want to follow them, you should try to engage somewhere else (I'm guessing you don't get the results you want elsewhere?).
In case you're not familiar with said rules: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
The forum is useful because of its users in spite of how it's run. Just like reddit.