I used to think this, but you'd be amazed how many small towns in Europe have train stations. The eastern third of the US is high enough density for this, we've just chosen to put our money into interstates and the like instead.
You can take public transport pretty much anywhere you want to go. It’s clean, safe, and generally reasonably priced.
The downside is that houses are smaller and more closely packed. By American standards, the kitchens and bedrooms are cramped.
But dystopia? Hardly.
Even if that’s only, say, 10% of the population in less dense areas, it could still make a significant impact on traffic and emissions as well giving an economic boost to downtown areas, since there’s now a reason for people to live near them.