> This is not how to learn anything.
You don’t learn anything by reading books? So if you have an interest in astronomy you don’t learn by reading books on astronomy? How do you learn, then? Must one go study to become an astronomer as the first step? Won’t you have to read a book on it at some point?
> It's way more meaningful to understand and pursue your own actual interests
What does this mean in practice, and how does it invalidate reading? Can’t you understand and pursue an interest in philosophy by reading philosophy books?
> than to humble brag by ticking the "correct" readings.
Who’s talking about humble bragging? Wether you brag or not it’s up to you, I don’t see anything on the website encouraging you to do so.
> Not to mention that talking about the best anything is basically meaningless, except for very tightly constrained achievements
The website is very upfront about how it works:
> We ask experts to recommend the five best books in their subject and explain their selection in an interview.
Seems like a good way to begin exploring. If you’re interested in a subject the website points you to someone they consider to be knowledgeable of the field, that person has recommendations to get your started, and they explain why they picked each one.
Maybe I missed something about the reason you oppose the website, but on the face of it I don’t see what’s so wrong as to justify such vehement disapproval.