Given that a user owns their feed, I'm not sure why this is a bad idea?
I want to take this critiques here seriously but there's not a ton to grasp onto. It definitely didn't feel great that AtProto built from bare ground, reinvented json-schema & OpenAPI for no reason. But ultimately this is one of a number of grievances that feels like doesn't really matter. It's stupid & dumb but in the end it doesn't matter. It's hard to tell which of these points really have hard & real impact. And which are just bias.
The general feeling is an unencumbered letting out of biases, which makes it harder to trust.