Paywalled, so I can't look at the details. And the details are going to really matter here. What's the paper's exact definition of "impartial"? That's going to determine whether the paper's proposal is sanity itself, or insane, or somewhere between them.
I think it's become clear, though, that "follow the science" has become an inadequate epistemology. Some scientists lie. Others do bad science, where the evidence does not support the conclusions. Then some non-scientists lie about science, and others find pieces in the "science" that support their desired position, and construct fine-sounding but cherry-picked presentations designed to mislead. Then people choose sides, and argue with their fingers in their ears for the position they prefer.
That is not an adequate methodology for arriving at the truth, either individually or as a society.