Hacker News Reader

Tik tok videos are speech, therefore banning tiktok is a violation of free speech

You are free to post the exact same content on any other platform. It's not the speech that's banned, it's the platform.

A bit of silly analogy but if a megaphone recorded everything about the person speaking into it and forwarded it to a semi-adversarial state, would banning that megaphone be a violation of freespeech?

Haven't read the bill, but I'll go on a limb and say it's not written to apply to all apps owned by semi-adversarial states.

It is substantially the same as the one passed in my state. The first sentence of senate bill 419:

> AN ACT BANNING TIKTOK IN MONTANA; PROHIBITING A MOBILE APPLICATION STORE FROM OFFERING THE TIKTOK APPLICATION TO MONTANA USERS

https://leg.mt.gov/bills/2023/billpdf/SB0419.pdf

Of course, it's a hypothetical to tease out why people think it's a violation of free speech.

A law this specific wouldn't even be valid I'm my country.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com