The energy is a mix of leakage current and active current. Leakage current can be thought of as resistance - it's how much current flows through a transistor that's off. This can be better based on the material, but gets harder with smaller transistors. (Thinking about quantum tunneling as a resistance is good to get intuition, but not good enough to help solve the problem. A material with a lower bulk resistivity will not help here.)
Active current is based on capacitance. Each FET has a little capacitor that needs to be charged and discharged every time the logic is switched - that adds up. Lowering the capacitance of each FET would reduce the energy required to switch it, but generally comes with bad tradeoffs. High-k dielectrics increase the capacitance, all other things being equal. But all other things are not equal, and they are used to create better performing FETs with lower power leakage.