The US is probably the only developed country in the world where this line of thinking is accepted as "yep, makes sense, pretty good approach"?
Or you could assume that the current prison system, in the States, is actually making recidivism rates worse by treating its inmates in such an inhumane way - hurt people hurt people.
One could discriminate between the two assumptions by comparing its recidivism rates with recidivism rates in the rest of the world.
> As you know, though, different crimes are punished in different ways, which makes sense.
Different crimes are punished in different ways. In most of the civilized world, punishment ranges from fines to more-or-less harsh limitations of one's freedom of movement. I don't remember corporal punishment being one of the possible consequences for theft.
Here you go. Looks like the US is not any kind of outlier. Some places do worse.
https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/recidivis...