I wonder how much of this can be attributed to medical bankruptcy. If you cannot afford insurance, get injured, can't afford treatment...pretty straightforward doom loop to an early grave
I wonder how much of this can be attributed to medical bankruptcy. If you cannot afford insurance, get injured, can't afford treatment...pretty straightforward doom loop to an early grave
Only 4% of US bankruptcies are because of medical bills <https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/post-partisan/wp/2018/0...>. A tipoff that [insert large percentage here] of bankruptcies aren't actually because of medical costs is that only 6% of bankruptcies by those without health insurance are because of that cause. The biggest cause of bankruptcies is lack of income, which health insurance doesn't affect.
91% of Americans have medical insurance, whether through their employers, or government programs like Medicare/Medicaid. That's compared to 95-97% in other developed countries because there are always some people who fall through cracks, like (say) a Canadian who doesn't get a new provincial health care card after moving, or a German who neglects to buy into a new sickness fund after changing careers. The only such systems with actual 100% (or as close to it as possible) coverage is something like the UK NHS, which does not have a requirement to show a membership card (because, well, there isn't one) to receive treatment.
There are things I'd certainly improve about the US system—decoupling primary healthcare coverage from employment, for one—but the way people online ~~lie~~ exaggerate it's not surprising that so many non-Americans believe that every American is one hangnail away from bankruptcy.
PS - Obamacare did not greatly expand coverage. 85% of Americans had medical insurance pre-Obamacare.
People exaggerating online certainly don't cause more confusion than the routine lies of medical providers, sending bills with completely-fictitious humongous numbers claiming to be the price. And then even if you do have "insurance" (which isn't actually insurance, but rather more of an anticompetitive protection racket), the provider and the "insurance" company both continue to keep the actual prices obfuscated with those fictitious numbers and a whole bunch of "adjustments", rather than ever just plainly stating prices.
There are certainly a lot of overly simplistic narratives about US healthcare, like every political topic. But the entire system is death by a thousand cuts of patently absurd behavior (like the above), that would be plainly illegal with any sort of sane regulation. Like imagine going to the grocery store, paying the cashier, and then getting shaken down months later by food distributors claiming that you only paid the cashier to bag and that you owe them money.
That's the name of the game, not unique to USofA. Once you have majority/monopoly payer (be that private insurance or tax-supported state health fund) it becomes a game of cat and mouse. Health providers try to extract as much per case as possible, insurance providers try to cut per-case payment to the minimum. Inflating list prices on provider's end, establishing various per-item limits and per-case adjustments on payer's end are the low hanging fruit towards the goal. State insurance systems just have this less visible as the patient is usually not involved in the invoicing process, but nevertheless it is there.
The sad reality is that there is very little to none incentive for list prices to remain low or reflective of actual cost.
There's also the challenge that not all coverage is equal here. The ACA (and certain follow-up legislation) set some baseline, and states may also have their own minimum coverage criteria, but it can vary wildly. The ACA's biggest impact was mandating coverage for common-but-critical things like childbirth etc.
Source: https://www.census.gov/library/publications/2022/demo/p60-27...
$1600 a month for health insurance
This inspired me to donate to an NGO that provides oral healthcare for the poor.
That's not 'only'.
In quite a few other countries that percentage is zero.
In Canada, with universal healthcare that cost $0 at the point of care, bankruptcies due to health issues is actually pretty high (15% for seniors).
Why? Because a big driver of medical bankruptcy is not the medical costs, but the fact you can no longer work and any assistance you get doesn't cover your cost of living.