The sad thing is that the UK has inflicted all the negative aspects of ID requirements on people without the consolation prize of a universal free ID.
If you have a job, rent a house, or have a bank account in the UK, you must have a government ID at the moment. Because people wanted that requirement barrier built so it could be used against immigrants.
You might as well say we should not have police because if they're required to beat you up if they saw you commit a crime then that would be bad. It would, but they're not, and it's the people who would intend that who you should oppose.
In several European countries, you absolutely do.
Why would anyone who wanted mandatory "ID please" checkpoints advocate for them before introducing ID cards when:
a) it makes no sense to advocate for them prior, there’s a natural sequence of dependencies.
b) it would hinder the introduction of ID cards and hence, mandatory "ID please" checkpoints.
We had that back when the government made it mandatory to have ID to be employed or have a bank account or rent a house. Not having an ID scheme didn't prevent it being made a requirement.