What’s ridiculous about it specifically?
I’ve studied linguistics and English is my 2nd/3rd language and I’ve never understood what all the fuss is about.
(My native language is highly gendered and inflected and hearing the calque “they” from English still doesn’t stand out that much to me)
Indeed. If any of these people complaining about pronouns were exposed to Japanese their heads would explode as soon as they tried to talk about themselves. Conversely, Finnish has always had ungendered pronouns, and Chinese only introduced them 100 years ago and then only in the written language https://www.capstan.be/the-gradual-rise-of-gender-neutral-pr...
https://public.oed.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-singular-they...
> Garner tracks the evolution of the third-person-singular “they,” starting in the 1300s, when it sometimes referred to unspecified individuals. (It’s still used that way today in such sentences as “This style guide will enlighten the reader in ways they never expected.”) But only in the 21st century has “they” been applied to specific, often nonbinary, individuals—as in “Alex asked that they be given a promotion.” This usage, Garner notes, took off with the rise of the transgender-rights movement following Obergefell v. Hodges.
1. Referring to an expression like "everyone" or "someone" (not a noun): "If everyone minded their own business". This usage goes to back to Middle English.
2. Referring to a noun that refers to a person who gender clearly cannot be known by the speaker: "This style guide will enlighten the reader in ways they never expected." This usage seems fairly traditional but I'm not sure if it goes back as far as the previous one. I rather suspect it doesn't, in which case it wasn't a good example in the passage quoted above.
3. Referring to a noun that refers to a person whose gender could be known but happens not to be known, at least not yet: "The burglar injured their hand breaking the window; we have sent blood samples to the lab for analysis."
4. Referring to a noun that refers to a person whose gender is known to the speaker but the speaker does not want to reveal the gender: "We have another witness; they saw you leaving the scene." (It takes practice to do this. I have on several occasions heard people accidentally reveal the gender when they didn't want to.)
5. Non-binary people: "Alex asked that they be given a promotion."
There used to be widespread usage of "he/she" or similar in documentation that was trying to edit out the old assumption of using "he" everywhere to refer to "the user". That was always a bit clunky, and "they" reads better.
Almost everyone who used to use "neopronouns" has given up and settled for "they", as well.
An example from thesaurus.com:
> English speakers have been breaking new ground when it comes to they, resourcefully applying this to a specific and known singular, e.g., My best friend from high school is famous now—too bad we didn’t stay in touch after they moved to California.
I came across another, different case in which a young native speaker of British English used "they" instead of "she": in talking about a hypothetical female person. I asked the speaker why they had used "they" instead of "she" (I can be annoying at times) and they helpfully explained that if they had used "she" then it would have sounded as if the person really existed. (They were talking about a sister they didn't have, or something like that.)
"You two, stop fighting"
"But they started it!"
There certainly are people using "they" when they know the gender, but they don't use "they" in every case, as far as I can tell, so presumably they are following some kind of rule with conditions in it (because people don't, in practice, choose pronouns at random).
What exactly is the "top" in this top-down relationship?
I feel that other people in here might feel that saying things out the way they really think might be detrimental to their employment status and hence to their well-being. In this respect it is a top-down imposition, it is true, with the “top” not being defined as a specific person or a specific group of persons.
And going a little meta, it’s high time for the hosts of this forum to implement a delete functionality.
I must admit, I've woven a hypothetical so thick I'm starting to be curious about what the opinion could be. It was meant a little tongue in cheek though :)
The paranoia dismissal should be left out of an honest discussion.
So you're blaming a nebulous .. them?