Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by buildbot | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

buildbot

Isn’t the idea that the (US) government can’t (technically) compel you to lie?

View on HN

"Just because you're right doesn't mean you won't go bankrupt in a court of law proving it."

That's real world wisdom...

The better question is: are you (or PyPI in this case) interested in a legal tussle with the US Gov?

You can beat the wrap but not the arrest.

I would think there are certain situations where a person might be compelled to lie, such as if you have a security clearance, have signed an NDA, or are acting as an informant. That is, a person may have to lie to prevent divulging classified or secret information through implication.

EDIT: One situation where the government cannot compel you to lie is if it violates your fifth amendment rights (self incrimination).

those are all things you actively agreed to, in advance, in exchange for some sort of consideration (job, not going to jail for illegal things you've already done, etc)

I have never heard any legally competent source say that the U.S. government cannot (with warrant or whatever) compel you to lie. I'm pretty sure that, in the case of a canary, they can.

That may be the case but if the cost of testing it is 5 years in jail while the case works it's way through the courts, few people will be willing to rely on it.

Please, we do it routinely. They're called "informants."

At the end of the day if uncle Sam demandeth, uncle Sam will haveth.

The US compels certain kinds of speech all the time.

The US government is not compelling speech, it's compelling PyPI to accurately reveal to the US government the contents of past speech that PyPI has access to. Compelling disclosure of certain kinds of data, when it's known, is a normal part of legal actions in the US and probably elsewhere.

You seem to be describing what these subpoenas have requested. This thread is about canaries, and whether the government could compel a company to keep one updated against their will.

The process is the punishment.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com