Hacker News Reader

Comment by justin_oaks | Hacker News Reader

Assuming you're being serious, the advantage of the cloud is scalability, avoiding managing hardware, reliable power, and reliable network.

You want to run your web app off your basement server? Go ahead, but if you have a blog post that hits the front page of HN, there's no way to scale up. If your home server has hardware failure then you're out of luck until you can get new hardware. Your home has a power outage or ISP outage? Your site is down.

If you can tolerate those things, great! I wish my employers and their customers would tolerate it.

View on HN

> Assuming you're being serious, the advantage of the cloud is scalability, avoiding managing hardware, reliable power, and reliable network.

Or in reality, it's weird transient failures you can't debug, and unexpected bills for some asanine reason. And scalability sure seems like something to avoid until you actually need it (as in the demand on the site is large enough, not that your performance is so bad you can't handle traffic).

Obviously I can be more cavalier with my uptime, as it is a personal server.

My first job out of college was a hybrid computer operator /programmer for a company that ran a state lottery. This was the mid 90s.

They had a complete backup site with redundant servers, modems (for point of sales systems) and a redundant staff because the cost of being down was so high.

We never had to use the backup site the entire three years I was there.

Everything agree with, until:

> but if you have a blog post that hits the front page of HN.

HN traffic is so small that unless you are using Raspberry Pi Pico, it is fine.

Your 5-year old Android phone probably can handle HN traffic just fine. (HN traffic is in a range of single-digit kilo qps).

Well, if you're serving reasonable amounts of text and not including a javascript kitchen sink. I mean yes, you probably should be serving library off an edge network, but I've seen stranger.

Then that goes out the window the moment you have any media on that Pi... ISP upload speed in the US is balls.

Oh, did I mention that most ISPs in the US don't allow hosting websites? So are you putting that Pi in a datacenter?

And, I forgot to mention, what happens with you piss off some bored troll and get DDOSed?

None of what you mentioned related to "traffic to a blog post from HN front page". I am just saying "traffic from HN front page" is a poor example of things that need "scale up".

Not disagreeing all the challenges you mentioned. Just "traffic from HN front page" is so easy it is a poor example.

TIL it's against Verizon's ToS to host a website on a residential account. Ah well, I guess I'll continue to roll the dice.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com