"So how is he going to pay online-only bills?"
"Can he read about politics as part of his duty as a voter?"
Paying bills online and reading about politics are not human rights either. There are alternatives available for any task he's expected to do as a member of society. "Since I know he's technically proficient, he's probably using the Internet as we speak."
That's a really bad argument, and I think you know it. He very well may be online as we speak, his neighbors probably have an unsecured network, but why is that a good reason to intentionally give the man internet access? He's shown time and time again that he uses the internet to commit criminal acts, there is no reason for him to have that access.This is not a human rights violation.