This eliminates the Dnipro as an invasion route and allows Russia to concentrate on defending the north.
Putin may not care much about Crimean civilians but he's not going to go through all this trouble just to make them suffer.
This eliminates the Dnipro as an invasion route and allows Russia to concentrate on defending the north.
Putin may not care much about Crimean civilians but he's not going to go through all this trouble just to make them suffer.
The Nova Khakovka reservoir fed not only the Crimea Canal, but three (or was it four?) other major canal systems... Irrigation canal systems. Without the dam, the erstwhile reservoir's water level is of course far below that of those canal systems, so they're all out of commission. And with them some significant proportion (a fifth? Something like that) of Ukraine's agriculture.
I am not sure why you believe these two things contradict each other.
It also requires that you assume Putin genuinely believes he's going to lose Crimea in this war, which seems questionable (a Ukrainian military conquest of the peninsula is a *huge* ask, much more so than just retaking the occupied Donetsk territory).
The tactical explanation, and especially the timing, really seems much more likely.