> The exact benefit premium membership gives you is hiding ads
The same can be trivially done with a browser add-on, which is exactly why their premium offering is a nonsensical one. I've been a premium member for several years and I view it strictly as a show of support for what they do, nothing else.
If they want the ad revenue, they need to control the delivery. Hence the push for the official app. Lots of people don't like the app, some don't like ads and they are opinionated because Reddit is a part of their routine. So, no, I disagree with you completely that offering a paid option to participate in Reddit on users' own terms will not be in demand.