I'm in general no big fan of locking people away so I agree with your statements in regards to piracy and jail. But the punishment needs to be higher than the benefit is for its users.
You compare Megaupload with p2p architectures. Of course torrents are used for criminal activities but they can't be stopped. You wouldn't compare twitter with Megaupload if you had seen Megaupload. The site was essentially like Netflix but for all movies in existence. Saying now that it's only the fault of its users if the site was designed for piracy in mind, is ridiculous.