The exceptions of course are 737 MAX (we all know why) and ATRs (which I'm not familiar with -- anyone know why they have a high fatal crash rate?)
The exceptions of course are 737 MAX (we all know why) and ATRs (which I'm not familiar with -- anyone know why they have a high fatal crash rate?)
ATRs are turboprops that fly a lot into relatively difficult-to-land small airports. Also, the accident rate under-counts the amount of flights they've actually made by more than some of the other aircraft.
It would be interesting to see statistics for maydays as well; most shorthaul flights have the advantage of having nearby airports for their entire route.
Turboprop aircraft like the ATRs are generally considered to be more dangerous than jets. I couldn't find a MTBF (Mean Time Between Failure) specific to the Pratt and Whitney engines that the ATRs use, but an AOPA article from 2017 suggests that turboprops in general are over three times as dangerous as jets[1].
Here are some potential reasons that come to mind:
- Turboprop aircraft typically fly at lower altitudes than jets do, where there is more inclement weather and less time to navigate to an airport in case of an engine failure.
- Turboprops are more complex as a whole than jet engines; there is just more to go wrong (variable propellor pitch, for instance).
- Smaller airlines are the main operators of turboprop aircraft. I don't like to suggest that they are less competent on the maintenance front, and certainly don't have any evidence for this, but maybe this comes into it.
- Most fatal aviation accidents occur on landing, and since turboprop aircraft are typically used for shorter flights, they will make more landings per mile flown (nautical miles, of course, in ICAO world).
[1]: https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2017/august/pil...
At least one crash, however (American Eagle 4184) was due to a flaw in the design: ice rapidly accumulated where it could not be dislodged by the de-icing system.
A third one was due to wind exceeding the airplanes design limits[3], the airport was known for strong turbulence and wind shear due to location and mountainous terrain, and the airport was permanently closed after.
The fourth one seems to be due to improper maintenance and counterfeit parts[4], causing the tail to fail.
There's also been a few fatal accidents involving the Hercules like the Svanfjell-accident[5] due to a misunderstanding of the height clearance and the Kebnekaise-accident[6], again due to human error as well as maps lacking correct height data for the area.
From what I can see[7], there's few if any fatal turboprop accidents involving the engines. So seems that at least here in Norway, the main reason is they fly a lot of stops on small airstrips located in difficult terrain, as well as being operated by smaller airlines with less organizational oversight.
Though I'm not expert by any means, and things might be different in other places.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wider%C3%B8e_Flight_710
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wider%C3%B8e_Flight_744
[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wider%C3%B8e_Flight_839
[4]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Partnair_Flight_394
[5]: https://aviation-safety.net/database/record.php?id=19660320-...
[6]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Norwegian_Air_Force_C-130...
[7]: https://no.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liste_over_flyulykker_i_Norge
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Eagle_Flight_4184
French-Italian collaboration, what could possibly go wrong?