If it takes someone to manually change it from green to red, that does seem to defeat the purpose.
For the 30 seconds where you wait for failover to complete: that is a 30 second outage. It's not necessarily profitable to admit to it, but showing it as a 30 second outage would be accurate
Maybe you want human confirmation on historic figures, but the live thing might as well be live.
There's stuff like this that can't be automated well. The automated result is far worse than the human-based alternative.