> CDs are a federally insured way for investors to receive a fixed interest on their deposit for a fixed period, in return for not being able to withdraw the money early without a penalty.
...still not spelling out what the abbreviation actually means - ok, it's in the paragraph above the one I quoted, but hidden away in a subordinate clause that's easy to overlook if you just scan the text. I was in the "Compact Disc" camp too BTW...
A Blu-ray disc that's guaranteed to last 100 years would really be something.
Of course by that time there would be problems with finding a device that could read such a storage medium, but I assume a custom one could be made easily with the technology of the 22nd century.
All BDXLs should last that long, easy. In fact Blu-Ray Mdiscs were rated for 1000 years - but they didn't even bother certifying BDXLs as MDiscs since they use the exact same technology. The BDXL 128GB quad layer discs are meant to be the most durable of all of them.
Rated by their marketing team, not by reality. Independent testing showed marked different results.
Better than regular discs? Yes. 1000 years? No. Not even close (10-50 years seemed the range, depending on conditions)
I can't find any results on Google that would prove otherwise either, if you have anything please link.
M-Disc PR released details of a DoD China Lake test that showed M-Disc was more durable than regular DVDs. They are, that’s not up for debate, though not by much & not all (as I’ll explain later)
The 1000 year claim is, however, utterly unsubstantiated.
The French National Laboratory of Metrology and Testing (LNE) did actual aggressive testing. M-Disc performance was low compared to other long term storage & comparable to regular organic DVD-Rs from Verbatim.
In fact it performed worse than regular organic DVD+R’s from MPO.
Longevity is a function of both the material stability of the medium and usability (of storage, of retrieval, of space, of scale, of complexity, of cost). If nobody can decode those bits, it doesn't matter if they are still in the medium. The most optimal storage system is not a single technology, it is a well-funded and well-managed institution. You need people to regularly check integrity of redundant archives and replace individual media when they fail. You also need people to migrate the entire archive to new storage technology when the current generation is growing obsolete. The institution has to regularly buy and maintain drives and computers that can read it, which is often overlooked. Another major issue is longevity and documentation of the data formats and encodings. The bits can still be on the medium, and your drive can still read them, but are you're out of luck if you don't know how it was encoded.
"Tape" is not a single medium, it is a class that includes some formats that are now incredibly difficult to decode. Look at this recent thread about what is needed to read from an old IBM tape format, it's an expensive mess: https://groups.google.com/g/bit.listserv.ibm-main/c/AOlRa0qx...
Custom special? Probably some form of the metal engraving encased in glass. GlassMasterDisc by Syylex was an attempt to do that for DVDs but I don’t think they’re made anymore.
Those actually were a LOT better than MDisc in practical tests
Of course! My only concern is that plastic parts often start getting brittle after 35 years or so and might simply not survive.
In the meantime I found an alternative a solution: there exist consumer-grade 3D printers with 50um precision - hooking up a camera with a microscope in place of the nozzle should be enough to produce pictures of e.g. 100um x 100um tiles and stitching them together to get an image of the whole disc.