But it is a sin to transmit your disease to others knowingly. No one is interested in broken epistemology.
And anyway, that’s all irrelevant because science is not defined by whether the results are exact or high precision or even highly reproducible. You seem to have a mistaken impression of what science means. If you are a curious person, it is really useful to understand how science is defined, and you can verify that social sciences are still science, and find out why social sciences really are sciences. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science
Math and logic are the fields that some people consider to be not science, because they’re not based on observing and analyzing.
“Social science is one of the branches of science, devoted to the study of societies and the relationships among individuals within those societies.”
What are you even talking about now? Sure there is a difference between social science and, say, physics, which is why they have two different names. Yes they are different subjects. They are both branches of science though. Why are you moving your own goal posts? You weren’t arguing earlier that “there is a difference” between social science. You were arguing that social science is not science, which is false.
I don’t know why you think casting doubt on Wikipedia using ad-hominem tactics is a good idea. That’s a pretty weak argument, you can do better.
And why did you bring up STEM? Only the S stand for science. Technology, Engineering and Math are all not science primarily because they’re not primarily based on experimentation and observation. They involve some science here and there, but they are not considered science disciplines.
It actually might be much more productive to cite some websites, especially if they’re actually trustworthy, than to claim someone somewhere agrees with you without providing any evidence at all. Let’s do some actual science on this question. I’ve given you two pieces of evidence that are widely trusted and widely cited, one of which was your suggestion. Now you give me two pieces of evidence that back up your claim that social science is not science.
This one I had saved somewhere https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/literally-psyched/human...
On psychology https://www.latimes.com/opinion/la-xpm-2012-jul-13-la-ol-blo... "But to claim it is “science” is inaccurate. Actually, it’s worse than that. It’s an attempt to redefine science. Science, redefined, is no longer the empirical analysis of the natural world; instead, it is any topic that sprinkles a few numbers around. This is dangerous because, under such a loose definition, anything can qualify as science. And when anything qualifies as science, science can no longer claim to have a unique grasp on secular truth."
And excuse me if I allow myself to add a 3rd one https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/cross-check/is-social-s...
Your third link doesn’t actually argue that social science isn’t a science, it’s just a plea to be more careful, which is fine and fair. The title of this piece fits Betteridge’s law of headlines: the question (‘is “social science” an oxymoron?’) can clearly be answered with a “no”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines Also many of the commenters on that piece disagree with the article and have some valid points that this opinion piece is lacking in robustness and factual accuracy.
So it seems like you’ve only linked to 3 opinion pieces by individuals, none of which actually back up your claim that social science is not a science, and for which there is little evidence of any widespread agreement, as opposed to Google’s dictionary definition of social science or the Wikipedia article on social science (that comes with over 3 dozen references) that I linked to. (BTW go ahead and look up any dictionary definition - OED & Merriam Webster both confirm that social science is a science.) I did search ‘why is social science not a science’ (which BTW is a biased priming question that presumes an answer - you can get lots of false information from Google this way), and the front page of results is a mix of opinion pieces, lots of articles that don’t actually challenge whether it’s a science, and pieces that flat-out contradict the question and confirm that social science is a science.
I do think there’s a stronger argument to be made here to maybe kind-of half support your point of view, but you’re not yet convincing me or anyone else here that social science isn’t doing science, you’re only providing repeated evidence that you don’t really know what either science is or what social science is. The reason your comments closer to the top got flagged is because they’re actually false.
My comment closer to the top got flagged because some people who work in social "science" don't like it if someone tells them the truth.
Why do you believe people downvoting you work in social science, what actual evidence do you have for that? I would love to see that, I want to know how to identify the jobs and motivations of people responding to me.
Regarding the downvoting, I don't have evidence for it, but you don't have evidence for your version either. My assumption is that you for some reason see the need to uphold social science as a science, and anything against that narration must be wrong automatically.
What is science? Please define it. What is social science? What does a social scientist do, and why doesn’t it amount to science in your mind? What does a biologist do differently?
Now answer this question carefully: why do so many people call it a science if it’s not? Why does social science have science in the name? Why do all the encyclopedias and dictionaries all define social science as a science, if you’re right? Why do you believe you know better than the experts that I’ve linked to? Things that might clarify the discussion include: why is it important to you to state that social science is not a field of science? What harm do you believe is being done by calling social science a science?
You’ve argued that social science is not a science because it’s not exact, but the natural sciences are not exact. You’ve argued that science seeks to explain things based on observation and analysis, but social science does exactly that. You’ve argued that social science is “different” from STEM, which is circular (The S stands for the same science that occurs in the term “social science”) and pointing at the existence of some unspecified differences doesn’t do a single thing to demonstrate that social science is not a science or is failing to use the scientific method.
What if we tried an approach with examples. What field as example is a social science to you?
Specifically, for one, please define “science”, so we can get to the question of what is and what is not science. The claim that social science is not science is yours to justify.
A list of social sciences is in the Wikipedia article I linked to already. Sociology and Anthropology would be good representative examples.
https://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/sociology/sociology-is-so....
http://cognitionandculture.net/blogs/benson-salers-blog/anth...
https://etiennefd.substack.com/p/the-difference-between-scie...
I define science as anything that is scientifically rigorous. That does not include humanities or social sciences, arts, philosophy, history etc.
Social science is not a science (I could agree on field of study) because there are too many possibilities involved in human psyche. "“Many researchers fail to consider that their measurements of brains, behavior and self-reported experience are profoundly influenced by their subjects' culture, class and experience, as well as by the situation in which the research is conducted,”"
An example of how social science can be dangerous is of how many people take the "Milgram experiment " canon, Eugenics, IQ, Social Darwinism, ... policy making based on social science studies .. It all goes into the same basket to me.
That's not a definition, it's a circular statement with no information. Please provide a real and functional definition that can be used to identify whether a subject is scientifically rigorous or not.
Your first link confirms that Anthropology is science. Your second link is false information content spam with no sources. People can and do experiment on society, the article we're commenting on is an example, the claim highlighted is obviously false. Your third link is outdated non-news - the AAA put the word science back in their statement the following year. Your fourth link is talking about humanities and not social science.
This is another Gish Gallop of non-evidence that fails to support your claim.
How many possibilities are involved in the stars or the earth or in chemistry or biology? Why does the number of possibilities have anything to do with whether a subject is science or not? Please explain.
Here's a list of research papers from multiple fields, some are scientific and some are not. Can you identify which ones are not science and which field they belong to? If it’s not science, say why.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26131-z
https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.17207
https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2220570120
https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.12597
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-33957-8
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.add5462
https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02820
Common man do you want me to copy-paste the definition of science from wikipedia here? You can look it up yourself. My obvious statement is that the problem I see is that some stuff that people want to label as science is not science because it is not rigorous enough.
> https://www.thoughtco.com/is-anthropology-a-science-3971060
You can read in the article that people do not agree on whether anthropology is science or not.
> https://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/sociology/sociology-is-so...
Well here we run into a problem, anything that you don't want to hear is either spam or false information.
> http://cognitionandculture.net/blogs/benson-salers-blog/anth...
Yes but that still shows that people argue about this stuff. This topic is not closed.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26131-z => Neuroscience => Science
https://arxiv.org/abs/2203.17207 => Mathematics => Science
https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2220570120 => Agricultural Science => Science
https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.12597 => Mathematics => Science
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-33957-8 => Physics => Science
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.add5462 => Hydrology => Science
https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.02820 => Computer Science => Science
Sure. I already did that, and you disagreed with it. WP’s definition supports social science being categorized as science. I’m asking you for the definition that supports your claim, because WP’s does not.
> You can read in the article that people do not agree on whether anthropology is science or not.
You can read in it that some do. The conclusion says that at least some of it is good robust science, which disproves your claim.
> Well here we run into a problem, anything that you don't want to hear is either spam or false information.
Not true at all. Did you even bother to read the article and look at whether it’s authoritative? Yourarticlelibrary.com is a content spam site: the entire thing. Did you even read the article? It’s full of misspellings and false and stupid sentences. The problem is you aren’t even trying to evaluate the quality of the links you’re pasting, after googling a biased question for anything to back up your incorrect points. I’d be absolutely embarrassed to defend this article, and you should too, it’s trash. Your response is resorting again to ad-hominem, you simply don’t seem to be capable of sticking to arguing that the content is true or think critically about it.
I know that people argue about this topic, I’ve in fact mentioned that multiple times. Too bad that doesn’t prove anything.
I’m glad you agree that some of those are science, because all of them except the math paper are categorized as social science. Every Single One. The math paper is not science, it’s math.
You’re proving to me you don’t know what you’re talking about, and not curious to learn.
Okay so social sciences I do not consider science because they are not rigorous enough (I did write this in the past three messages...). The rest of the WP 1st paragraph I agree with.
> You can read in it that some do. The conclusion says that at least some of it is good robust science, which disproves your claim.
I did not send you the link to prove my claim. But you can derivate from this that there is no consensus on this topic. You'll probably argue that it is a closed topic because wikipedia says so, but I do not agree.
> Not true at all. Did you even bother to read the article and look at whether it’s authoritative? Yourarticlelibrary.com is a content spam site: the entire thing. Did you even read the article? It’s full of misspellings and false and stupid sentences. The problem is you aren’t even trying to evaluate the quality of the links you’re pasting, after googling a biased question for anything to back up your incorrect points. I’d be absolutely embarrassed to defend this article, and you should too, it’s trash. Your response is resorting again to ad-hominem, you simply don’t seem to be capable of sticking to arguing that the content is true or think critically about it.
If you want I can mark for you the texts that I consider truthful.
> I know that people argue about this topic, I’ve in fact mentioned that multiple times. Too bad that doesn’t prove anything.
What are you trying to prove? Who decides that social science is a science?
> I’m glad you agree that some of those are science, because all of them except the math paper are categorized as social science. Every Single One. The math paper is not science, it’s math.
Neuroscience < Biology < Natural Science
Agricultural Science < Multidisciplinary < Biology
Physics < Natural Science
Hydrology < Multidisciplinary but mostly Natural Science
Computer Science < Formal Sciences
Sorry but you seem to be quite wrong on this one. The only credit I could give you is on multidisciplinary sciences, but there again I would exclude social sciences as valid parts of the respective science. Mathematics is often considered a science.
> You’re proving to me you don’t know what you’re talking about, and not curious to learn.
Do you want to hear my opinion of what I think about you? I think you are proclaiming a false sense of intellectualism by being pendant where it is absolutely unnecessary. I've already stated my point of view multiple times and it is simple enough that you should understand me. You do understand my point of view but continue to inquire information from me as if to show me a lesson. I have the feeling we continue in circles so unless there is something else to tell I'd like to close the topic.
I’m just trying to get you to be even a little bit rigorous, but you haven’t been able to put any rigor behind your claim whatsoever, you seem unable to argue your claim, because you simply keep repeating it. You’ve resorted to ad-hominem instead of discussing the issue in most of your comments in this thread, and you’re doing it again.
The evidence you’ve provided of a so-called “debate” over whether social science is a science is incredibly weak. Most of it was irrelevant to your specific point because either you’re confused about the difference between humanities and social science or you read the click-bait headline but didn’t catch the conclusion. Most of what you brought so far was single obscure opinion pieces by one person that fail to show any significant disagreement about social science. The existence of someone who says something hyperbolic on the internet is not evidence of a lack of consensus.
Meanwhile, the single Wikipedia link stating without hesitation that social science is considered a science represents thousands of people who agree that social science is a science. Wikipedia is generally pretty good about acknowledging a lack of consensus. So if you think you’re right that there’s enough lack of consensus, then you should edit the Wikipedia page and get it to permanently state either a lack of consensus or permanently state that social science isn’t science.
Yes totally I think you should scour Puja Mondal’s “article” to pick out the sentences that are true among the many sentences that are untrue. Maybe doing that exercise would help you see how hopelessly terrible that article is. I’m stunned you’re doubling down on this particular point. What is the value of some true sentences in an opinion article that has many false statements, and is written by someone with no expertise?
BTW I didn’t define those papers as social science, the science journals nature, science and PNAS did. (For example https://www.nature.com/collections/ccjddcabab) Agriculture, being a human endeavor, is considered part social science, and any given paper can lean heavily into the social science. The paper you called CS is really computational social science, and obviously so since it’s trying to recognize human emotion. All the papers listed are multidisciplinary and all involve social science. You are further demonstrating that you don’t know what social science is.
So what’s your expertise? Why is your opinion on social science even relevant?