I'm pretty sure my father wasn't turned gay by PFAS and other forever chemicals (which weren't even in widespread use when he was born), it's that he grew up in an area and an era where coming out as gay could get you murdered (if you were merely ostracized, you got off easy), and it wasn't until societal attitudes had shifted that he felt safe enough to leave my mother and be with who he wanted to.
If I had to worry about that, I (a lesbian) would probably still be in the closet, too. And I probably would have married a man to deflect suspicions, much the same way my mother was a beard to my father.
The explanation given above (increased acceptance, decreased violence/killing) seems more likely than the initial explanation for increased LGBT presence
But you are of course free to present whatever studies you wish
Hello? Sagan called and wants to know which specific literature has convinced you to hold these beliefs.
1. We still don't know why people are LGBT.
2. If everyone is feminized then there should be a clear decline in lesbians, transmen and bisexuality in women.
Are there hormone disruption sue to pfas? Yes 100%.
Does that make people gay probably not.
[0] Colon I, Caro D, Bourdony CJ, Rosario O: Identification of phthalate esters in the serum of young Puerto Rican girls with premature breast development. Environ Health Perspect, 2000; 108: 895–900
The probably not is in reference to PFAS making people LGBT not to people being feminized.
Thanks for the very basic explanation of endocrinology, unfortunately it does not support the OPs claim, you're at worst arguing with an invisible post or at best, stating something that doesn't disprove anything in my claim.
And I'll reiterate the claim is not that PFAS does not feminized people, the claim is that if we were to see it affecting our sexuality, SPECIFICALLY making us move from being straight to LGBT then we should see be able to see clear data showcasing how females produce more testosterone & having more male-align brains which would make them more likely to become Lesbian, Trans or Bisexual against control - which to my knowledge no study have shown.
>This is also why soy products may increase breast size in men but not in women
If you mean breast size as in they work out and get bigger muscles in the chest area because of protein that came from soy-based products, then yes I agree.
If you're making the argument that it increases estrogen because soy contains "plant estrogen" then no afaik you're wrong.[1][2]
[1]https://www.fertstert.org/article/S0015-0282(09)00966-2/pdf
[2]https://www.fertstert.org/article/S0015-0282(10)00368-7/pdf
Breast growth, erectile dysfunction and decreased libido in a 60-year-old male who drank about six pints of soy milk per day. With no other cause indicated. His symptoms ceased after he stopped consuming all this soy.
As they could not determine his testosterone levels before he started to ingest soy milk, it's impossible to know if the man was already suffering from low testosterone.
And in my sources they have studies that specifically look into people that are 60+ and there was no such link found.
So it seems the question hasn't been conclusively answered. But the case study hints at the possibility of an excessively high intake of soy having an estrogenizing effect, even if we don't know why. Maybe he had some particular configuration of gut bacteria that helped this process along, or something. More research needed.
And again even if we take your source at face value it's a 60 year old man (which mean less testosterone production) who consumed an absurd amount not something most people will consume.