But it sure looks to be bimodal. Marker of the really bad, and the so-good-it's-closed
On occasion, when I get invitations to participate in moderator elections, I look to see if I recognize any of the candidates. Once or twice, I have looked through the candidates' resumes, and one thing that struck me was that some of them did a lot more down-voting than up-voting. Make of that what you will.
https://blog.codinghorror.com/new-programming-jargon/
They explain why they deleted the most appreciated question ever in Stack Overflow, and how they magnanimously let you look at a few scraps of the answers (but not to all, these are DELETED!), and why we can't, after all, have nice things.
> Does this effect have a name?
If I wasn't against ad-hominems, and to avoid giving undue credit, I'd propose to call this effect "Jeff Atwooding". As in, the cool answer by Thurston on contributing to mathematics has been jeff atwooded recently.
The question on the original post seems more grey-area. It isn’t really a math question that can be answered in a math-y way, but it is the sort of thing that some folks might benefit from seeing anyway…
That's a good question. It should have a name.
We've seen it around for a long time on stackoverflow and all stackexchange-sites. I bet there's a very long German word for this kind of behavior?
It's a combination of extreme persnicketiness mixed with smug arrogance and some amount of glee in punching-down.
StackOverflow advertises itself as a place for precise questions and answers, and explicitly not for open ended questions and answers. It tells people who sign up not to post open ended questions and answers, and encourages participants to flag same, and moderators to close same. To then be bitter and rude because that happened exactly as the prophesies told you it would, is unreasonable.
That's a good analogy!
These moderators act as angry old men booing people out of their lawn. People who were having innocent and wholesome fun, and overall improving the neighborhood.
It's the same kind of guys who call the police on kids selling lemonade.
You can't go to a vegetarian cook-out and start cooking burgers because "I want burgers" and then mock the hosts for being unhappy at you. Well you can, but you're the jerk in that situation. You can't go to Wikipedia and start posting questions and answers and saying "I wish it was StackOverflow you angry OLD MAN horrible moderators".
> "People who were having innocent and wholesome fun, and overall improving the neighborhood."
Misusing someone else's site, in a way the creators and existing users don't want it used, in a way you agreed not to use it when you signed up, is not "improving the neighborhood".
No one cares about "the creators", and MOST ESPECIALLY NOT what Jeff Atwood thinks about their questions, answers and comments on stackexchange sites. Atwood is gone anyway, he cashed-out and moved on.
The existing users are many and varied (I am one) but for whatever reason the gamification attracts a high level of zeal from certain personalities that tend towards petty authoritarianism and persnickety behaviors. As useful as these sites are (at least up to now), this is a serious problem.
You can tell because you don't want to go to Quora or Reddit for your open ended questions; allowing unfettered open ended questions generally makes sites become overrun with low quality memes which drives the more hardcore users away. You recognise somehting about high quality at StackOverflow which is why you want to go there, but then you want to bring the low quality stuff with you. And when that's ruined StackOverflow you'll chase the next site which has narrowly scoped content and demand to ruin that too. Stop.
> "No one cares about "the creators", and MOST ESPECIALLY NOT what Jeff Atwood thinks about their questions, answers and comments on stackexchange sites. Atwood is gone anyway, he cashed-out and moved on."
OK, not the creators, the /owners/. Y'know, "my house, my rules", that kind of owner.
These days I'm skipping Stack Overflow entirely and jumping straight to the docs, unless it's a common question that I can never remember properly (like some esoteric git-fu command).
The answers on SO are outdated or crappy. When you can't ask questions about an evolving framework without it getting marked as duplicate, then the answers quickly lose all value. And the people that were answering because they wanted to give back (not because they want to farm karma) are leaving.