One thing I didn't see discussed anywhere in this entire thread is how impossible it was to get a cab at night (at least in Boston). On a Friday or Saturday night it was absolutely impossible to get a cab past 11:30pm. When I would rarely find one, they would ask for $50 cash to go to the destination, which would have been a $10 ride if metered. I frequently walked 5 miles home from a party at 1am. I have even heard stories of girls sleeping over at random guys apartments since it was likely safer than walking home alone. All of this completely disappeared when ride sharing appeared.