RISC-V makes it possible to have Open CPU or even OpenSOC on an OpenBoard. That basically wasn't even possible before. We are even getting to a point where there are open PDKs. There are libraries of analog IPs that are open. Now that there are lots of options for OpenCpu people are going after the missing stuff. Open Ethernet PHI and so on. There is also now a big movement in regard to making the tooling open source to compete with commercial tooling. OpenROAD, OpenLane, Verilator and so on.
The benefits of this are amazing. Project like Core-V, OpenTitan and so on simply wouldn't have happened.
You have things like RISC-V International, the Chips Alliance, LowRisc, Google and many others working on all aspects to make a fully open ecosystem possible.
But that doesn't change the fact that most SoC and most board in the world will be property, RISC-V or no RISC-V.
> RISC V is not extension free
Not sure what this means. Exertions are part of RISC-V. The waste majority of extensions used in the real world are all part of the same standard put forward by RISC-V International.
Most of the non-standard extensions came about before there was a standard for them, and most are converging to the standard pretty fast.
And even if OpenSPARC had a open spec, but was only for 32bit. The 64 bit version would never become a standard. You need more then air dropping a spec. You need people to continue to push it forward and evolve it. You need to build a community around a standard. Sun simply wasn't interested in doing that, they just made a spec and left it there.
OpenSPARC had some success, being used for space by ESA for example. But it didn't get adoption in education. The venders of embedded chips were not interest. But the time was just not ready, the OpenSource ecosystem wasn't ready and the publisher (Sun) didn't care about embedded. The seperation between chip makers and fabs had not fully happened yet.
Saying that RISC-V is like POWER is just fundamentally false.
Saying RISC-V is like SPARC 32-bit is slightly more correct, but misses a whole lot context that is non-technical.
Yes we should give Sun credit for what they did with SPARC. But RISC-V is quite a different thing.
ESA's OpenSPARC-based LEON. But note ESA has already decided to replace it with the RISC-V based NOEL.
Having the ability to make open end to end things is valuable even if its not in every product. Linux shows up in lots of places where people are not aware and that is a good thing. The same thing will happen with RISC-V.
And for people who like open, there will be product for those people. There are companies working on open board devices, laptops, boards and so on. And in the future maybe those could be open chip. The costumers of those products will not care if the PC at Media Market is a propriety computer with Windows on it.
Your attitude would basically be that 'its hardly different' when OpenSource started to grow. But it was and is actually different for a lot of people and for the industry.
The idea that things are only relevant when media market costumers can buy them is just sad and depressive.
Getting Debian officially supported is one of the necessary steps towards that goal.
Which is the reason why they were created in first place, UK's school system.
Neither of them originated from a neutral source.
SPARC is quite alive for Solaris customers, and there are still plenty of them.
Regardless, it doesn't change the fact that they were there first.
Anyone that thinks basic ISA being open source, will prevent extensions, proprietary boards or boot firmware are fooling themselves.
Sure, it may do for a couple of maker community projects, Arduino style, and that is about it.
Fujitsu has announced plans to transition away from SPARC by 2030. Oracle has laid off their staff, after the M8 in 2017. ( https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SPARC ) If SPARC isn’t dead, then it’s in palliative care, and not far behind Itanium.
Shame because SPARC T series was interesting and I wonder what it would look like today at modern geometries and using chiplets.
Point 2, it was there first.
Only 32 bit was open. And the 64 bit was a major change for Sparc.
RISC-V is inevitable[1].
Only one I didn’t see was Apple, hell even Raspberry Pi is there.
But I can imagine there's interest on their part in using something like RISC-V in supporting chipsets; modems, power mgmt, disk controllers, etc.
That and having something in their backpocket "just in case."
Closed source = extra cost, licensing red tape & so on. However small, it's a bother.
Need an OS? Grab open source one. Want that + 'secret sauce'? Grab BSD flavour OS & add your secret sauce. Want OS with custom user interface? Grab open source OS & add custom UI shell.
Going closed source for anything where open source does the job, just means extra development effort, or paying 3rd party $$ while (often) not necessary. And eg. $0.05 royalties / device matters when it's a part with $3 production cost.
On the hardware side this is a much slower moving train. But same principle.
There's a reason people pay for ARM tools. There's a reason people pay SiFive and StarFive to use the rocket core generator for them. (heck, there's a reason I still use WDC65C02's in new designs.)
While I'm generally a fan of open source software, open source hardware is a different beast. The cost of copying an open source hardware design is noticeably higher than the cost of copying open source software.
You always pay for what you get. If you're lucky, you pay in cash.