It's possible to support and encourage free access to scientific knowledge while not supporting IP infringement.
It's possible to support and encourage free access to scientific knowledge while not supporting IP infringement.
Not even theoretically. IP is the concept that people should be prevented from reading things without negotiating with the people who own them. So "free access" quite obviously requires that future "scientific knowledge" be excluded from IP protection, and that people who already own "scientific knowledge" be compelled and/or bribed into relinquishing their ownership.
And to expand, those options would also require the government to define what is "scientific knowledge" and what is not. Or else, I could just call my paper a satire and Elsevier could become a publisher of satires.
Is not supporting IP infringement a necessary precondition to supporting and encouraging free access to scientific knowledge?
I think there are many people who believe that this knowledge should be out there regardless of potential copyright violations.
This is assuming that spreading knowledge as effectively as possible is the only goal. Even if you take a utilitarian approach to ethics, I doubt anyone has this as their only goal.
> The laws in question aren’t really about morality anyway.
I think what is and isn't related to morality is at least somewhat subjective.