That's because it's civil forfeiture. There is no presumption of innocence in civil law; it's part of criminal law.
That's because it's civil forfeiture. There is no presumption of innocence in civil law; it's part of criminal law.
From my perspective, “cops can take your stuff unless you prove your innocence because it’s not a criminal proceeding” is a distinction without a difference. Cops shouldn’t be able to just take your stuff.
The government has to prove suspicion of wrongdoing on a preponderence of the evidence.
Edit:
You can show up to a civil forfeiture case as a claimant, refuse to answer other questions under the 5A, and walk out with the goods if the judge doesn't think there's any wrongdoing.
Edit: rhetorical question as I don’t think you’re actually of the opinion that it’s reasonable.
So naturally, because in most civil cases its the other party's inaction that's supposed to be punished, courts adopt "guilty until proven otherwise" stance. Now it's the other party that has to show a receipt signed by you, or to show their bank statement that says they've transfered money to you, etc. That's one reason why there is so much paper trail in business and commerce — so that's when someone sues you, you could use all that paper to cover your ass.
(Referendums notwithstanding.)
The difference being that who needs to prove what can be quite flexible.
In civil contexts however, the legal standard is the much lower "preponderance of evidence" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burden_of_proof_(law)#Preponde...).
For example congress could legislate that some specific crimes should use "preponderance of evidence" rather than "resonable doubt" or even require that the defendants prove their own innocence beyond resonable doubt.
In the case of civil forfeiture I suspect that the individual whose property was seized has a constitutional right to appeal in some way, but also the constitution has little to say about the rules of that appeal process.
[1]And whom, even if they still had those resources, quite often wouldn't be able to afford the costs associated with proving themselves innocent to get their stuff back in the first place.
E: Oh that's how you do italics on HN.
You have to prove the cash did not commit a crime. This sounds absurd, but it's easily prove, the cases are named things like United States vs. $117,000 in Cash and State of Missouri vs. Gold Jewelry Worth Approximately $1400.
But if that's not absurd enough for you, boy do I have some good news for you! Since the case is against the property, you the previous owner of that property don't automatically have standing. Court cases in the US are based on common law (except maybe Louisiana, who knows what goes on in that Bonapartist shithole), to appear in court at trial, you have to prove that you're actually a party to the case. It's automatic if you're the defendant in a criminal trial (or plaintiff in civil), or the prosecutor... but third parties are usually told to pound sand. And the case clearly names the property as the defendant.
Don't let me overstate it... as far as I know, no one's ever been denied standing when petitioning this, but it's another hoop to jump through. One that will cost you money.
If they seized less than $10,000 or so, forget it. It'll cost you that to get the stuff back. So they tend to target lesser amounts now days, knowing that no one will bother. And if it's a higher amount, they'll often try to settle... "hey we know it will cost you another $5000, so why don't you take half and we keep the rest?" Of course, you're still paying the lawyer a few grand to get that far, and it will come out of your $5000, and not their (using that word pains me) half.
If you haven't retched in your own mouth a little, then I still haven't properly explained how bad this is. Go read.
But why? You lose your presumption of innocence, you lose a guaranteed defence attorney, and you still face years of prison and maybe even the chair... there is a reason why offences with gravest punishments (that is, crimes) have pretty strict procedures and proof requirements set up around them.
0 - note that if this happens to your property, it sure will feel like it is happening to you. Lawyers will be happy to lawsplain their BS theory[2] to you for a nominal hourly fee. This will not make you feel any better for having been robbed at gunpoint.
1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_rem_jurisdiction
2 - Spoiler alert: the theory is exactly as stupid as it sounds.
Imagine that it's 1804, and a ship shows up in port carrying contraband. The sailors on the ship didn't know about it, they just make sure the boat doesn't sink. The owners are nowhere to be found, they live in London or Paris or Antwerp or something, and you'll never be able to arrest them for it (this is the pre-extradition world).
What do you do with the contraband? You need a formal law to deal with seizing it. And this serves as the framework for our modern civil forfeiture laws. A case would be entered into the dockets something like "State of New York vs. 152 Gallons of Whisky" or whatever. The whisky itself committed no crime, there can't be a criminal case.
Next time on the program: why "assault" in "battery and assault" doesn't actually mean the same as "assault" in colloquial speech.