Not saying you're wrong, but... what is your basis for claiming that this is true?
Now if a planet killer passed us every year then we probably would have hit them by now (or provided a gravity slingshot to alter its orbit!), so it follows that it must have a large orbital period :p
But to more fully answer the question look to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elliptic_orbit
Notice that the object with an eccentricity of 0.8 has a much faster speed as it approaches the mass it is orbiting. So, to extrapolate, objects with a high eccentricity will be moving much faster as their semi major axis decreases (as they get closer to the mass it is orbiting). Faster means less time to detect the object. Less time to detect the object means we have less time to react to the object. Less time means planet killer.
And keep in mind the time periods we're talking about for some of these objects measure in the tens of thousands of years. So we don't really get a chance to record these objects for "next time".