We already surpassed that point of equilibrium long ago. Humanity is now consuming 1.7 Earths of resources every year. Some countries like the US consume a lot more than that.
https://www.overshootday.org/how-many-earths-or-countries-do...
If you are spending 1.7x your income, how much money you have in the bank becomes extremely relevant. Are you broke tomorrow, or do you have enough savings for 1,000 years
In some cases we've already passed the peak of certain resources. See this paper about peak minerals from 2012.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09593...
If you have a finite, non-replenishable resource, then you need a budget for how long you want it to last to come up with a consumption Target.
No little girl who grows up seeing few, if any women, have children will think to herself "I want 2.1 when I grow up!". But, all must do this, or fertility rates never recover. If not all girls do that, then some must instead say "I want 4.5 when I grow up" or "I want 8.9 when I am a woman"... which seems even less likely.
It's an inevitable, inescapable mathematical fact.
All women will not need to have 2+ children for an equilibrium. Some women and families will want 0 or 1, and some will want more. But in any case, people obviously respond to incentives, and the people who think there is an "inescapable mathematical fact" that population will simply continue trending to 0 ignore this fact entirely.
It might even be true that with the right incentives, they could convince the childless to have children. Unfortunately, he doesn't seem to get that just because there is a theoretical incentive that could work doesn't mean that same theoretical incentive is anything anyone could hope to afford.
Assuming that fertility decline is irreversible, this would mean that you should have specific examples of entire populations that have died not of disease or conquest, but reproductive ennui. I don’t think so.
no i shouldn't
you should give examples of this trend reversed, the original claim is "this is easy", "humans respond to incentives".
but guess what? there are no examples of this trend reversed. Briefly, for a decade, Iran maybe. Your turn to defend the original claim that "just give them some incentives and everything will be just fine".
2. The "ennui" as you refer to it, is clearly a modern phenomenon. It couldn't have happened before now.
3. We've already seen this verified experimentally with animal models, multiple times. Despite having unlimited food, water, and entertainment, the populations crash and never recover.
If you don't think so, it's just because you haven't bothered to think about it.
I’m somewhat familiar with Calhoun’s studies if that’s what you’re referencing, but I don’t think they’re perfectly applicable to human societies where there’s no outside force maintaining everything for us. Reproduction slows, accompanied by economic stagnation and infrastructural failures, and all of a sudden we’re not in our little mouse utopia anymore. These little collapses aren’t necessarily bad. It’s artificially pushing onward in the name of GDP that I think leads to even bigger collapses down the road.
Fertility rates tend to fluctuate in relation to stressors like resource availability.
> No little girl who grows up seeing few, if any women, have children will think to herself "I want 2.1 when I grow up!".
Why not? Baby booms are very real. This is normal human behavior.
Edit: Just one example would be the short-lived COVID baby boom. Remarkable how responsive people are to changes when you think that this is mathematically impossible.
In 50 years, the childless people will be dead, and the children of breeders will be alive with children of their own. Rinse and repeat every 50 years.
Unless every person on earth is in agreement to not have children, the problem solves itself.
If they convert children more quickly than others can have them, then this still goes downhill. How do you even model that? Is it fertility rate - conversion rate = 2.1?
I suspect that conversion rate to be significant. I'd be shocked if it's not closing in on 1.0 (or already blown past it).
We can do a gutcheck mental exercise here. The Duggars have 20ish children. Will they reach 400 grandchildren, or even come close?
Duggars might not have 400 grandchildren, but I bet big money that they'll have more than 2.1 grandchildren.