I grew up with two abusive parents. You have no idea of what that is like. There is no communication adaptation that saves you from the abuse. They will fly off the handle because they want to, and they will find a reason, even if there is none. The coping strategy is to avoid and keep away.
OP sounds like they had a short tempered but caring parent. The situation was alleviated by their adaptation. We all have our weaknesses and strengths, and I am quite sure OP's parent is not the only human to be quick to judge. After all, look at your own comment :)
Don't make being a fallible human something bad. We need to tolerate each other's flaws, and compromise towards each other.
> ...I grew up with two abusive parents. You have no idea of what that is like...
...I reply - how can you make any assertion about what I know? I haven't said anything about my own childhood. Abuse is a harsh word but it's not a yes or no question; there are shades of abusiveness. What you went through sounds awful, and I certainly don't mean to diminish that, but please don't thereby suggest that others who have suffered less, have not suffered at all. Even mild psychological abuse can have far-reaching consequences, and I'm sorry that I will not elaborate, but I do have some relevant knowledge and experience about this subject.
> Don't make being a fallible human something bad. We need to tolerate each other's flaws, and compromise towards each other.
I agree, the world needs more genuine compassion - I intended, at least, to send some compassion towards the OP - but from the original post I don't agree that 'fallible' adequately covers it. That's only my opinion though, and as another commenter pointed out, based on incomplete information.
You don't have to justify or alleviate your views. It's all good conversation. But let's keep the focus on OP, and let's not make very, very persistent commentary on their parent's behavior.
Its unfounded to call their parent abusive without more information
That said, how would you describe a person (particularly a caregiver) who causes others to walk on eggshells because of their random unfounded outbursts, and refuses to back down when given reasonable explanations for the things they have become upset about? And not just once or twice but often enough that it has had a measurable effect on OP's behaviour. That sounds abusive to me.
Again though, as you pointed out, it's not appropriate for me to continue to speculate on this; I just wanted to elaborate on my original comment to make clear my reasoning.
I dunno man, if you as a kid have to come up with strategies to -not piss off- your dad during -normal- regular conversation, maybe there's an issue there?
Maybe the dad had some issues too, who knows
Im on your camp.
The father sounds anxious and protective. Child figured out a hack, as we all figure out hacks to optimize our interactions with other people (all of them imperfect), to avoid that diversion, and life goes on happily. Calling the father "abusive" is honestly grotesque, and it is the sort of petty, detached-from-reality moralizing that leads to everyone hiding any real world details lest they get the boorish, cliched response.
It's akin to the sort of over the top, rush-to-conclusion relationship advice common online.
"My husband forgot a McDonalds drink cup in my car last week and now it started leaking out of the bottom!"
"Abusive! Manipulative! Gaslighting! Lawyer up, hit the gym and divorce his ass!"
"Hack"/"Maladaptive coping strategy" - pot-ay-to/pot-ah-to
With respect, I'm not sure there's a middle ground for us to meet in here, and I don't have anything to add beyond what I've written elsewhere.