I've been using Rancher Desktop for the past 6 months and I haven't missed Docker Desktop a single time.
Of course there are also organizational differences, Podman seems to be more of a community led open-source project whereas Rancher is ultimately trying to sell enterprise kubernetes management software.
In my experience, k3s looks great on the surface but I ran into quite a few issues operating it in a single-node use case.
If I was looking into this today, I'd definitely explore Podman/Kind instead.
The main rationale for using Rancher is that the CLI is the same as Docker. No modification to any script was needed.
Podman might be better, I can't say, but for what I use it for it doesn't really matter.