In my view the fundamental disagreement between progressivism and conservatism is whether or not there are tradeoffs at play, whether or not we can have our cake and eat it too. A conservative is inclined to say that we can't and a progressive is inclined to say that we can.
The conservative is usually right, but all progress (whether social or technological) depends on when they're wrong, hence the eternal conflict.
Edit: Another way of saying this is that the conservative plays as if she is in a game with a concave payoff function and the progressive as if the payoff is convex.