>Will the screen be as bright and sharp?
When I had mine replaced with aftermarket one, I asked about that and they showed me a phone with a screen of supposedly comparable quality and even offered an option to come in later and check the phone mid-repair for a 15€ fee. (That was a fee to let you back up data off of the phone if you didn't want to go trough with the repair)
>What am I going to get with an off-brand battery?
Many shops will offer warranty so that if the capacity degrades quickly they will replace it for you.