I think it should be illegal for them to bar skiplagging. I hope lawsuit blows up in their face and the FTC and Consumer Protection step in to bar airlines from fighting it.
But it's clear for all to see that it's nonsense. First, complexity is no defense for anything. Second, the resource utilization is strictly higher in the skiplag case: the demand on the first leg is the same, so demand can't be justification either.
If the price for a multi-leg trip can be lower, that must be because the earnings on the second part of the trip outweigh the loss on the first part. That would also mean the single leg passengers are subsidizing the remaining legs.
Meanwhile AA is the only airline flying non-stop from Jacksonville to Charlotte. They offer the best product there, and charge accordingly.
Products aren't priced according to their cost to produce, they're priced according to what the market is willing to pay for.
Wouldn't then the skip-lagged price be the asking price?
Check prices for flights from Paris to Martinique and to Guadeloupe. Each will cost about $1000, with a layover on Guadeloupe or Martinique, respectively. Or, you can pay $1500 for a nonstop to either one.
That $500 buys you the avoidance of 3 hours of your life switching planes at airports.
Since there is less demand to fly from point A to point C via point B, the price point is lower.
What would make A->B more expensive than A->B->C?
A->B is a higher demand ticket than A->B->C, so the market bears a higher price for that ticket. By getting off at B, the traveler has "stolen" the difference in those two prices from the airline, as the airline would have charged the skip lagger or another direct flight customer a higher price.
I think ultimately the incentives work out to exactly where we are, airlines will simply ban travelers from their services when skiplagging is discovered.
There's no reason to offer services to travelers who pay less.
Quite a few smaller cities offer subsidies to carriers to bring traffic to their cities. Those same cities might not be happy when travelers use the subsidies to go to the big hub for cheaper and instead. It might even be contractually agreed that the carrier has to make sure they go where they're supposed to, thus the rules we see.
Why even involve other routes at that point, offer $20 or $0 service on that link.
1) Longer voyages use less fuel as a multi-leg because aircraft don't have to load as much to make the full flight direct. See: "intermediate stop operations". Those 15h and 18h flights are really bad for fuel efficiency, and they can't carry as much cargo. That's a reason Asia<->USA cargo flights frequently stop in Anchorage Alaska. They're also more complex for staff (can only fly so many hours at a time, need to carry relief pilot(s) after X hours)
2) Sometimes transiting a particular country is difficult, so that routing would have lower demand. Sometimes I fly from Paris-USA-Toronto, and that incurs extra headaches (visas, ESTA, luggage restrictions (e.g. food)) that many avoid.
The cost of the flight is irrelevant.