It was a long time ago so my memory may not quite be right, but basically KDE 3 was quite mature and powerful. The aesthetics were reasonable - no where near Gnome which looked really good back then, but still decent.
Then they released KDE 4 with "Plasma" which had a lot of half baked UI experiments that looked terrible and basically everyone hated. They really didn't listen to users at all, and just pushed through stuff that made no sense at all. They broke a lot of the desktop UI because they added the stupid goal of making it work on tablets too (they were the hot new stuff at the time), despite the very obvious fact that nobody was going to buy a KDE tablet. They even tried to sell one for a while!
It's a little like Gnome's mad decision to move menus to a hamburger, despite that making no sense and essentially everyone hating it.
Probably the thing that characterised the situation most was the "kidney bean". Something the internet seems to have wilfully forgotten (the only reference I can find to it is a comment on LxQT "remember the awful kidney bean?", but you can see it in this screenshot:
https://kde.org/announcements/4/4.1.0/
It's the button at the top right. I can't even remember what it was supposed to do, but it was always there, everyone hated it, you couldn't remove it, and they refused to budge. Of course it was eventually removed. Look at the terrible styling in that screenshot too. Compare it to GNOME:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNOME_2#/media/File:Gnome-2.18...
Essentially they took a system that people liked and changed a load of things in obviously terrible ways, and then refused to budge when people said they didn't like it.