Its really more of a paperwork/comiance thing than anything. I.e. genaric drugs. Source- I've designed medical devices and food processing equipment for 20 years.
OP seemed to suggest that medical devices was rife with situations parallel to McDonalds/Taylor, and that just doesn't seem to be the case; partially because the landscape is more complex in terms of who pays, how liability is distributed, and how the maintenance work is done, etc.
Which isn't to say device industry doesn't have lots of its own problems, they just look different.
I was making exactly the opposit point you are.
I have actually worked directly with the manufacturer of the pumps in those machines (Watson marlow), and also designed and saw through to clinical release many similar complex medical devices with the same exact pumps.
The situation is nearly identical between these two examples, it's just the names of the forms you need to fill out are different, and the division of the company that supplies your components is different, but it's all the same thing just a different name.
However, my point was not meant to be about the pump design nor the regulatory bodies involved, so I think we are just miscommunicating. My fault for quick replies.
I was responding to "There are so many of these situations in medical devices." by which I took you to mean that there are many parallel situations the the McDonalds/Taylor issue in the linked article and the franchises inability to keep them in service, or accept 3rd party help in doing it; I read this as the core point of the article.
When I said "things are more complicated" I meant the relationship between the various entities and how systems get deployed, managed, maintained, etc. doesn't look the same.
So is that what you meant?
It's possible you just mean there are similar technical issues in the pumps, something I'm happy to accept you have direct experience in; in that case I just misread you. If you had said there are similar (identical) pumps in some medical devices I would have understood it that way.
It read to me like you were making a far broader claim.
I'm still saying the opposite, I'm saying that those 2 industries (food equipment and med devices) are actually very similar in the way they operate. Having direct experience in both.
Good manufacturing practices, maintenance, etc. Are all the same no matter the application. Things are remarkably similar if you look past the surface level.
What I’m having trouble with is seeing a parallel with the franchisees position in this story, in medical devices.
If you’ve seen something you think is equivalent , I’d be interested in hearing about it , but it just doesn’t match my experience.
From and engineering and prod dev point of view I can see some parallels, fwiw. That is pretty obvious .
The dialysis industry is dominated by 2-3 large players who dominate the market, reimbursements, everything. They are Da Vita, Fresenious and I think there is a smaller third one.
Dialysis machines are very similar in practice to ice cream machines. They have peristaltic (and other) pumps inside with wearable parts that need to be replaced on regular intervals for not only reliability and safety concerns, but for biological concerns. Bugs grow inside them, even though thy have a daily self sterilization cycle they run. So they need to do preventative maintenance every few months and change out plastic wear parts inside like pump heads, seals, valve seats, etc. Keep in mind these machines are used constantly, these companies view an empty seat at a dialysis center like lost revenue, so they do there best to keep the machines busy.
Da Vita buys Gambro Dialysis machines, Fresenious makes their own. In both these cases there is a huge volume of disposables and accessories that go with these machines, both the daily disposables but the PM stuff too.
Lots of these dialysis centers do things to improve their bottom line that is off label. They do things like washing and reusing dialyzers which are explicitly single use. They do so with other stuff also.
Some newer systems are starting to use different techniques to not allow this, not allow these kinds of practices.
This isn't just dialysis. So many medical products have the classic razor/razor blade model and they typically actively design in proprietary lock in features so as not to loose out on that precious razor blade revenue.
There is some tech parallel I agree in e.g. protecting consumables , but that’s an aside in this context , and largely symptomatic if the way health care is paid for in US that drives towards a razor:razor blade model.
Anyway that was a long walk for a short drink of water!
But it's a damn ice cream machine.
The stakes get a bit riskier when it comes to medical devices because it's much easier to imagine the scenario where you tamper with a pacemaker, you're going to kill somebody. You tamper with a dialysis machine, you're going to kill somebody.
Same problem, different stakes.
>But it's a damn ice cream machine.
It's a machine holding fluids that are highly conducive to bacterial growth, and is a pain to clean because it has tons nooks and crannies. Someone dying (if there's a preexisting condition) or getting seriously sick due to subpar cleaning is very plausible. People get sick from improperly maintained ice machines[1], and those are arguably simpler and are holding less hazardous liquids (plain water rather than milk).
What I don't agree with is the proprietary lock out. Franchise owners should be able to replace the pump header with generic options.
The generic parts don't matter because the parts are tested to be suitable replacements
It's no different than car parts.
That's why I'm saying they need to label it if they serve rc not coke, just say what they're doing.
If they use one brand of straw that is approved vs another brand of straw that is also approved they don't need to label it, there is not material difference.
That's what I'm saying the parts in the ice cream machine are, not materially different.
The comparison you should be making is if they changed the ice cream base mix they put in the machine. Yes, in that case they should tell customers they are using soy milk or whatever, but If they use a different part in the machine that is equally suitable then it matters not.
It's no different than for the origami manufacturer.
It's all covered in ISO 13485 (and another similar standard for the software portion if your product contains software). It's called the risk based approach. You define what's called essential performance or your device, things it must do or the patient or caregiver is harmed. You then do a FMEA to determine what failure modes exist, and what the result of each failure is. You then make sure you have mitigation in place for each of those situations. You then document that all, get it signed off internally, by the FDA, by your notified body, and by the test house (for 14485, FCC testing, etc). All that makes up the stack of documents that allows you to sell a medical product.
It's no different if it's a generic product or a new novel one, same process same standards.
For food machinery it's also thr FDA for things like design and materials, and it's the local health department for those items. It's a similar but different ISO standard you need to meet depending on the specific machinery.
The stakes are actually higher for the ice cream machine. Inproper use of the ice cream machine could kill dozens. A pacemaker malfunction would just kill one at best.
It's why airliners need to have triple redundant systems, doubke fault tolerant. Medical devices only need to be double redundant, single fault tolerant.
I (dont) love it when people whonhave not ever designed a real medical device that's actually on the market make claims about what it's like to design a real medical device that's actually on the market.
> Poorly cleaned ice cream machines at a Washington-based burger joint were linked to a listeria outbreak earlier this year that landed six people in the hospital, three of whom died. Two of those who were hospitalized told investigators they had milkshakes from the same restaurant before getting sick.