I haven't seen any news on since January, and no concrete shipping date. I signed up on the announcement email list and haven't seen anything there either (or at least I think I signed up; I don't even see an acknowledgement email.)
That's not really a criticism or doomsaying about Intel or SiFive from me -- I'm really interested to see what they have -- but they could do with a better communication strategy.
Actually 2024.
SiFive P870, Tenstorrent Ascalon, SOPHON SG2044, Ventana Veyron, and more.
To directly compete with AMD/Intel they are going to have to be within the same ballpark of performance and cost about the same and consume about the same amount of power. There is simply no way in hell that is going to happen in 2024, not with the amount of catchup they have to do. Even Tenstorrent's own Jim Keller expects their Ascalon to be behind Zen 5 in raw performance / GHz, and Ventana's slides show it barely beating 2021 CPUs[1] which are in turn already massively outperformed by current-gen ones[2].
I fully expect a few RISC-V products to be only a generation or 2/3 behind within a couple of years, but that is simply not enough to be a direct competitor.
[0]: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2309.00381.pdf
[1]: https://www.servethehome.com/ventana-veyron-v1-risc-v-data-c...
[2]: https://www.servethehome.com/amd-epyc-bergamo-epyc-9754-clou...
It is the XuanTie C910 open source core. It has been available for many years.
I have no reason to question Jim Keller nor Wei-han Lien ability to deliver, with their proven track record of delivering.
Tenstorrent presentation late last year talked chiplet availability in 2024. That's the best estimate we can work with, for Tenstorrent specifically.
There's multiple other companies and cores we're aware of, and then the others we don't even know of.
e.g. Rivos has a strong team that's been silently cooking something for a very long time now. It could emerge at any time.
Add 3-4 years for cores to make their way into CHEAP mass-production hardware. People who describe this as "not in the near future" are probably still in school.
Not a decade. For sure not "at least a decade".
If your benchmark is x86 from ~2016-2018 then maybe. But the competition is moving forward as well (and Intel, AMD and ARM have a lot more money to invest into R&D)
So they might well hit June 2022 M2 performance, or thereabouts.
Sure, M1 or M2 class RISC-V hitting the market in 2026 or 2027 is hitting an old performance mark and Apple will have moved on.
Even if not the absolutely fastest thing in the world at that point, M1 performance in 2027 is still going to be a totally usable machine for most people for most purposes. I'm typing this on an M1 Mac Mini I bought in November 2020 and I can see absolutely no reason to replace it any time soon.
You can make whatever comparison you want between M1/M2 and x86.
Wouldn't they need to implement a bunch of additional extensions which RISC-V doesen't currently have just to reach feature parity? That alone would've introduced significant delays.
Also it took Apple 8 or so years to build a competitive desktop/laptop CPU. They released their first custom ARM core in 2012 and likely relied a lot on what they learned while working with Cortex so it's not like they started completely from scratch.
And we're talking about Apple, very few if any other companies are willing to invest as much time and resources into a product targeting a stagnant or even shrinking market (desktops/laptops) with very low margins. I don't think Qualcomm can't design something that would be competitive with M1/2 they probably don't just see a lot of sense in that financially. How would RISC-V change this?
Of course there are political reasons for Chinese companies (being increasingly cutoff from western tech to invest into RISC-V) which might be more important than financial ones. So a shift to RISC-V would be almost guaranteed to increase our reliance on China which in no way could be viewed as something positive...
> I can see absolutely no reason to replace it any time soon.
And presumably you would be fine to replace it when as machine which is just as fast in 5 years just because it used a RISC-V CPU despite there being significantly faster ARM/x86 devices on the market?
Apple doesn't build or learn anything. The people they employ to work there do. When those people go to another company ... e.g. a RISC-V company ... they take that learning with them.
Near Zen5 (projected) performance shown in Tenstorrent slides. M2 is not anywhere near that. Apple would wish.
Yet their ISAs are much more complex and thus they actually need to invest that much more money.
I could make a similarly unsubstantiated claim that their chips are much faster than RISC-V ones because of that (of course they are unambiguously faster it's just that this is not the only reason).
And anyway if RISC-V is to become competitive it will have to become much more complex as well..
Debate won't prove it, but it's true and time will tell -- and not very much time, at that.
> Debate won't prove it,
I find this (almost) religious style fanaticism about something as mundane as an instruction set quite fascinating.
Anyone who knows what they're talking about will tell you the same thing. If you don't want to listen to me then listen to Jim Keller. Or ARM star designer (ARM7TDMI, Thumb2, among others) David Jaggar.
RISC-V is inevitable.
> CISC dogmatism
Besides the fact that your understanding of what CISC/RISC means seems to be stuck in the 90s and the distinction is pretty much irrelevant at this point, you do actually realize that ARM is a RISC architecture?
> blatantly refusing to accept simplicity has inherent value
For microcontrollers? Sure. For high-end/general purpose chips? RISC-V cores will have to implement many 'optional' extension to become competitive.
>if RISC-V is to become competitive it will have to become much more complex as well.
Yes, by CISC dogmatism, I was referring to this.
>blatantly refusing to accept simplicity has inherent value
With a touch of CISC propaganda:
>seems to be stuck in the 90s and the distinction is pretty much irrelevant at this point
Thankfully, you won't have to wait too long, now.
RISC-V got on-par feature-wise with x86 and ARM, as of December 2021, while keeping itself simple.
>RISC-V enables the best processors
The very high performance implementations of RVA22+V will begin to appear as soon as next year. And that'll be the end of it.
>RISC-V is inevitable.