Sounds like you have never heard of the 4% rule[0]. Further, there are reasons to withdraw funds above ordinary living expenses, such as for gifts and donations.
>you have no idea how long you'll live,
Of course you do, within a range of probability. And there is insurance available to minimize the risk of uncertainty.
[0]https://www.fool.com/retirement/strategies/withdrawal/4-perc...
Does it really matter from a tax perspective?
Most likely, no.
If you are in a tax-deferred account (IRA/401k) then all the money distributed is going to be taxed at ordinary income tax rates.
If you are in a regular brokerage investment account, then both your long term capital gains and qualified dividends are taxed at the same favorable rate.
I don't see the point in re-investing dividends if you are going to take out cash in the same amount within less than a year.
The difference is cash flow. Obviously if your only income source is dividends, at some point you'll have to sell some of the underlying asset for the cash.
4% is just a rule of thumb to give you an idea of what your savings should be relative to annual spending.
The simplest method: look at your portfolio's worth on January 1, and take out the appropriate amount. Let the remainder ride.
So roughly:
* Year 1: take out 4%
* Year 2: Year 1 amount + inflation from Year 1
* Year 3: Year 2 amount + inflation from Year 2
* […]
* Year N: Year (N-1) amount + inflation from Year (N-1)
Is there? I haven't heard of this but admittedly had not thought of researching into it.
It would be a game changer to be able to buy an insurance policy that guarantees a monthly payment indexed to inflation starting at age, say, 85 until death.
(1) Planned, time-limited expenses that decrease net worth. For example, a child's college education. If you've budgeted for it, this is fine.
(2) General market wobbles. My net worth increases or decreases by tens of thousands in a day, just because of what the market did. (No, I don't have all of my assets in the market, but enough.) If the long term trend is downward and/or not keeping up with inflation, that would be a worry, but a dip here and there is also fine.
Is net-worth decrease a problem outside of these scenarios? Even that depends. It's probably still "no" if there are more income sources (e.g. social security, inheritance from parents) that haven't kicked in yet and will make Number Go Up again when they do. Less obviously, if you're going to run out of money at 150, that's not likely to be a problem. If it's at 75, that very likely is a problem.
It really is possible to save too much, though few do. Telling people to plan for an infinite retirement, which is basically what you're doing, is also bad advice. There's no virtue in scrimping and saving more than you really need to.
Completely wrong:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trinity_study
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Bengen
Principal liquidation is just fine and has lots of theoretical/historical analysis to support it, with (tens of) millions of people doing it as we speak.
Every quarter you drawdown your networth decreases to cover your expenses. Then you hope it maintains/stays the same by the stock market predictably reliably recovering from your 1%/quarter (4% drawdown/year) sale/gets offset by dividends, etc.
To me it seems it might be noise but there is for sure a period where your net worth decreases as you spend your "nest egg". Especially more so if the market doesn't just go straight up over time on average.