Stop partying. You're destroying the planet when you do.
Nobody needs to party.
You should not just make everything illegal, because you will need freedom of speech, too.
Like, snark aside, I said "we", not "they", intentionally. There's a whole lot of people working on these problems. That these folks aren't targeting commercial shipping does not mean in the slightest that it's not happening. When I go to town meetings and say "hey, high-density housing is good for [town]!", it's not somehow less legitimate that I'm not going to the next town over and advocating for it there, too.
No matter how you try to spin it, it’s a stupid argument.
"I don't like cruises. Cruises also cause harm. Let's ban cruises."
They're okay with banning cruises because they don't like them. Well, I don't like parties, so let's ban them too.
It's easy to "give up" things you don't enjoy, but you don't get to decide what other people enjoy. Maybe cruises to other people are the highlight of their life. You don't know that. You can't know that.
Every reason you give to take something away that people like they will eventually use on things you like.
Article also mentioned sulfur oxides. Those should get better as ships are forced to convert to low sulfur fuel,
All of the local air quality concerns would disappear if their protest is effective.
GT : Gas Turbine DLE: Dry / low emission LNG: liquefied natural gas
The good news is that across the world, this sort of hand-flapping is being ignored. In reality, we have already begun doing the right thing. We're already averting the worst-case scenario. But that isn't a repair job. We're slowly the rate of getting-worse. We have to do more to arrest that, to get to a net-zero state and then a net-negative state, because we can't predict that whoever we stick with the check will then be in as advantageous a place as we are to pull that brake.
This has immediate and short-term benefits even if one is too selfish to care about our grandchildren and great-grandchildren. Within living memory, rivers in the United States were too foul in which to swim and now, for the most part, they're not. Cities in the West were choked with smog and now, for the most part, they're not. And bringing it back to the topic at hand: cruise ships foul the ports they land in; you can smell it on shore and the trash they leave in their wake is obvious, and as a side benefit they also have extremely disproportionate climate impact. "What if...we didn't do that?" is not a difficult question and not one to rend one's shirt over.
Doing the right thing is better for us, now, as well as for our descendants.
I'm aware of current progress (worked there myself a bit) and past successes on environmental issues.
The only reason to trot out "well if you believe that, why would we do anything at all?" is to discourage action because it isn't perfect.
Some places somewhere will have this near future state, others will not.
But you (and I! I've done this too!) probably don't need to trivially junket through the Med or to have a weekend in Costa Rica to self-actualize. If we want to do it, we should pay for our externalities. A cruise ship's externalities are extremely fucking high, and they're paid for by...nobody, and all of us, at the same time.
What you're really saying--whether or not you know it, and I don't know if ignorance or knowledge is worse here--is that we should "just" come back to this in twenty or thirty or a hundred years and in the meantime now we have created a silver-platter excuse to do nothing and continue the outlandishly negative global consequences on everyone for a hypothetical future that you can neither predict nor roadmap.
Here's another one: once energy storage is solved as you posit, maybe then cruise lines should exist. If people want them. Until then, they should be priced with their externalities in and if that kills them (it probably will!) then they failed capitalism, gg no re.
I can't tell if it's a refusal to believe that large-scale negative changes that have already begun have an inertia that makes them continue to make things worse, or an inability to conceptualize eventual realities beyond certain time horizons, or else some hardline "I need to satisfy my urges whatever anyone else says" thing... but it's disappointing that folks who get so much benefit from being part of society so vocally and proudly refuse to participate in making a positive contribution to it.
Like some think tank who wanted to demonize environmentalism just made up this idea that the democrats are gonna force salads on people and it apparently resonated.
What concerns me about aviation is that the fuel isn't sufficiently taxed and that empty flights are often made just so that the airlines can keep their airport privileges.