Combine that with the lack of "third places" [0] for parents to socialize with other parents and you end up with a rather disfunctional society in which fewer couples are willing to have children.
Combine that with the lack of "third places" [0] for parents to socialize with other parents and you end up with a rather disfunctional society in which fewer couples are willing to have children.
https://populationeducation.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/a...
The number of people per family has been dropping in the US for a long time, the baby boom was the last 'bounce' in that graph and that was over 60 years ago now.
The number of children per capita went from 36% to 22% in the same time
https://www.statista.com/statistics/457760/number-of-childre...
and
https://www.statista.com/statistics/183635/number-of-househo...
"Churches, cafes, clubs, public libraries, gyms, bookstores, stoops and parks" are not exactly in short supply in the United States.
The problem is that it's difficult to get a critical mass of people out to them regularly.
Getting in a car to go drive somewhere is a huge pain in the ass. Doubly so if you have children and you have to secure them in carseats and pack all the stuff they require.
Third places work where you can walk to them from your home. As long as we stay glued to car dependency, we won't have them.
Except for church, going to most of these places is going to be counterproductive for the kind of person the article is about.
These people go out to these places, yet are "invisible." The social norm (at least in America) is to not talk to strangers unless there is a reason. Especially for an older male, approaching strangers is often met with disgust/shock just as the article mentions.
Yes we do, people traded all the good person-to-person interactions that are probably critical for human evolution for facebook.
The churches and synogogues in my town had dozens of clubs that were completely non-religions, ski-club, scuba-club, travel club, etc. Since going to church/temple became uncool, so did going to the clubs. We've replaced it with social media. One of many examples.
Getting in the car is not a pain in the ass if you have kids, doubly so if its worth it and limits screentime.
And again with the "cars are evil routine"... do you realize that the interior of the US was vibrant and well connected with many "3rd places"? This is a region of the US where it might be 10-60mins to the next "3rd place" by car, and by many accounts, society was much more healthier even with the added commute time.
I can’t speak to the interior US and how lovely it was or wasn’t.
I grew up in a car based suburb. It didn’t really have much for people to do. My grandma went and left because she couldn’t drive and was bored. I couldn’t afford my own car until I was 25, and I left shortly after anyway.
I could easily see my dad being very lonely while I was young. Everyday he went to work and then spent the rest of the evening ferrying everyone around.
He’s now doing social things like playing badminton etc. That will probably stop once he gets too old to drive.
1) it's not about being "cool". I have no issues with religion, but I am not religious and I see no reason to go to a religious institution to meet people who skew religious. It's that simple.
2) clubs are around without churches but have the same issues: they tend to be aimed at the youth. And we're unfortuantely past the days where having a single adult around a bunch of minors is simply okay and considered completely platonic.
3) You must be in a very high CoL area because the church clubs I saw growing up were nowhere near as fancy as ski and scuba.
It has nothing to do with religion in the same way that Schools have nothing to do with education.
Like sure, you can make meetups happen at schools and school events can bring general community together (well, not NOW given a whole cacophony of cultural shifts. But 20+ years ago), but for very obvious reason your institution will be stereotyped for having young kids/parents and a focus on learning. Not a place for a single 20/30's adults to casually hang out.
It's the same with church. Outside of a donation drive (which I am fortunate to not require) I can't imagine any reason for me to willingly visit a church in search of friendships.
>and you need not do #2 to do #1.
but they will be skewed by #2. I don't want to be showered in "Praise God" when I simply want to find a friend to chat with a few times a month and talk casually with. I don't want to make people who care a lot about their religion uncomfortable because I do not share the same beliefs.
I'm not looking for philisophical fights about God like some edgelord atheist on Reddit; they have their space and it's not for me. And that's fine.
Church aside, it doesn't address the general issues I have with club participation.
The conversation is about the "male loneliness epidemic" so fathers and older men, not just 20/30's adults should be included as well.
my condolences, but ultimately I can only speak for myself. I was raised Catholic so it's not like Ive never set foot in a church. It's just not a scene I want to be around. For me, I'd be just as hesitant if a school hosted as Ski club as if a church did for the reasons I described. Maybe it'd e different if it was my alma mater offering various alumni activities (of course, to advertise donations), but I am very far away from that campus.
>The conversation is about the "male loneliness epidemic" so fathers and older men, not just 20/30's adults should be included as well.
Sure. But I have to admit that I am not yet a father nor older man (at least, if we define "older man" as 40+. I can't speak for them (yet). I only wanted to chime in that I don't reject churches because "they are uncool". I'm not older but I am well past the age of caring about such matters. And I don't think any of my immediate friends would give that reason either.
If that works for you, that is great.
Personally, I strongly dislike segregated clubs, both ideologically and in practice. I want to interact with people of different backgrounds and avoid inadvertently carving myself into an echo chamber, so segregation (in any dimension) feels a step in the wrong direction for me.
the hackerspace that i visit has one kind of demographic, and the kybernetes meetup that i recently attended, quite another, which is yet very different from the people at the irish folk session or the meetup for self employed people, or the digital nomads meetup.
a single group that has a representative distribution of all sections of society does not exist
That is a strawman, and you could make the same argument about any combination of clubs you belong to, as long as they don't include the whole planet.
I simply have no interest in a club that explicitly excludes half of the population. A men only club in my mind is just as appealing as a "white people only" club. I.e. not at all.
but i was not even thinking about male only groups when i read your comment. i was only trying to point out that segregation along many dimensions is kind of unavoidable.
gender and racial segregation (and maybe religion) are actually the exceptions here. yet, i have to accept that most of the groups i join are predominately white males. but it's only a problem when others are explicitly excluded and not just missing because they have different interests.
every group is its own echo chamber, and the only way to avoid carving yourself into that echo chamber is to join multiple groups.
You're attempting to sell a solution that already failed in the marketplace of ideas, that is church. Because churches were tied so strongly with different clubs, they were dragged down by the same anchor. The problem was we had no other social 'third places' in place, and the greedy hand of capitalism was there to extract as much money from people looking to do something. When the internet rose to power you suddenly had a 'free' (terms and conditions may apply) alternative.
>Getting in the car is not a pain in the ass if you have kids,
Right, that's why people write papers called "The Contraceptive effect of car seats". I do believe more research is needed on your part.
Also, somehow its always the people that never publish (you, I can tell) that are the quickest to cite "research". You can publish anything, haven't you heard of the 'replication crisis'? I have kids, know lots of people with kids and while its maybe anecdotal evidence, getting kids into the car is the least of my worries. Sounds like a dumb excuse for people that think they need a reason to not have kids.
Columbus on the other hand, I could run to a suburb across the city, do my thing, and be back in less time.
I self-isolate far more in places like Austin than Columbus, largely due to the hassle of getting to/fro
I can't speak to public transport... growing up in a rural area I've always been predisposed to driving whatever bucket I had :)
It's so starkly different of a driving experience, I have to assume it compounds the time seen on their routes!
in beijing or any other large chinese city you can't go anywhere with public transport without spending an hour traveling from home, and any two interesting places are at least half an hour away from each other.
in vienna i can cross the greater part of the city in half an hour and most places of interest are within less than 15 minutes from each other.
To point out the obvious, this is a choice. And one with fewer trade-offs post-pandemic. For example, we bought our house in '21 from people moving a few states to be closer to their family, while we were moving there to be closer to our family. I am hearing this as a much stronger trend nowadays, vs the prior decades' "I have to move to NYC to get a job" ethos.
As an anecdotal example. I have one child. (close family size 3)
I have one sibling. (close family size 4)
My dad has 4 siblings. (close family size 7)
His father had something like 7 siblings (10)
Even if your family lives close, you still live close to far fewer people than past generations, especially ones that are close to your age.
> To point out the obvious, this is a choice
It may have been a choice for you, but it is not a choice for everybody.
Both my and my wife's extended families continue moving from one place to another for various reasons, often for work, so it's not like us moving closer to them today would guarantee any sort of proximity in the future either.
This is not an uncommon situation nowadays.
I don't deny that this is a choice, I'm contesting whether this tradeoff had diminished outside of WFH situations.
In an up or out world, there is a cost to not chasing TC too.
The point is simply that if you pick up and move every time you can get a raise, you are going to end up far from family and thus have that problem. But not doing that has become a more viable choice lately, especially once you understand the downsides of being far from fam ~ what we're talking about here.
The trend is that MORE people are allowing themselves to be closer to family, not that everyone does it now. Sometimes the tradeoffs are still painful - but often less so than before.
EG: if your lead REALLY wanted to be closer to parents, they can try rearrange other things (eg where they work) over time.
Doesn’t that actually prove the op’s point? People are not moving away from the metros in which their families are, so of course the largest metros would grow larger.
Personally I am very very hesitant to move cities for an economic opportunity. And that is entirely for financial reasons; if something happens to me, at least I can easily move back in with my parents.
That's assuming people's parents are already in the desirable metros, which is often not the case. These metros are experiencing a net increase from migration (except during COVID), so more people are moving in than out. Internal migration is disproportionately done by young people, so parents or aspiring parents of young children are likely moving away from grandparents. The "I have to move to NYC to get a job" ethos remains strong, though there was a pronounced drop during COVID young people are still much more likely to move than other demographics and their destinations are primarily the large cities: https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2022/07/theres-no-pla...
This may seem like a thing due to social bubbles, but the numbers do not bear it out. Prior to pandemic years (stats almost impossible to find on that yet, plus I'd wait another year or two to let the noise settle) Americans have never been less mobile in recent years than ever in the history of the nation.
I've pointed it out as part of our general malaise of the past 50 years. People in general are very hesitant to uproot for economic opportunity compared to the historic norm.
One other big difference is families don't move for the current patriarch/breadwinner either - both both societal and practical reasons. Big opportunities may also be less, but that's simple speculation. People's expectations in life and not accepting tradeoffs also may be part of it as well.
Family size is certainly part of it, but the Boomer generation belies that as the only or maybe even major cause. That generation began the generations of putting grandma in the nursing home vs. living inter-generationally. It certainly wasn't for lack of kids per adult.
The suburbs also seemed to happen around the same time.
Edit: Since this fact always gets initially downvoted, some sources from a previous comment:
https://www.brookings.edu/research/despite-the-pandemic-narr...
https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/jep.25.3.173
I've read more on the subject but sources going back further are difficult to immediately find.