Its stunning to me that these changes have managed to alienate so many people across the spectrum. Its not just the higher barrier to entry for the lowest tier that is earning complaints. The value of the miles earned was always much less important to me than the value of the occasional upgrades the status provided, or very occasionally the special support phone lines.
Perhaps the reality for the program really is that only the "whales" matter. We certainly see that play out all over the software industry. But if that's the case, it sure changes my porpoise-sized travel habits. My loyalty will now be to Amex moreso than an individual airline.