The second screenshot is a diff that compares the LLM output with the original book.
It also works with Harry Potter, but the API behaves weirdly and after producing correct output in the beginning really quickly, suddenly hangs. You can continue generating the correct words by doing more API calls, but it only does a few words at a time before stopping. It clearly knows the right content, but doesn't want to send it all at once.
I think there is some output filtering for "big" authors and stuff that is too famous that they filter in order to avoid getting sued.
I wrote more details about the weird Harry Potter behaviour here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37614697
And just because something could do something doesn't make it a violation.
How many bytes do you think a million compressed books takes? Consider that the way these models are trained is basically completing the next symbol based on the previous words, which is how most compressors are made.
I wonder if this might be because Slavboj might be a monist/physicalist, and you might be a dualist[2]? If that's the case we'd all argue until we're blue in the face, if we don't at least recognize this underlying difference. For the record, since I've studied biology, I'm probably closest to some form of mechanism[3] (due to the rejection of vis vitalis [4] in early 20th c. )
Of course, you could also just be a very skeptical monist mindful of the kluger hans effect[5] and working from there.
Let me know which (if any), maybe we can still find middle ground!
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physicalism
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mind%E2%80%93body_dualism
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanism_(philosophy)
This is all becoming akin to the 'but on a computer' for patents.
It's exactly the issue here. The capability doesn't matter, what matters is the scale of it.
Would you be ok with your car billing you every single time you exceed the speed limit because "there already are speed cameras out there" ?