I have 2 debit cards and two credit cards from UK banks, and my partner has the same. I genuinely don't think I've ever had 3DS reject a transaction for either of us.
> a fully dysfunctional system and yet somehow it has become solid because a "less" secure one has lost some people some money.
No, it's solid because of legislation. Improving the technical details doesn't help the situation, as most of the issues are legislative.