First person shooters may well breed the next gen of fighter pilots or snipers. Or maybe they'll enhance someone's dadflex and save a child from incoming danger.
If you say Factorio is fine, then you can't say anything else is any different.
First person shooters may well breed the next gen of fighter pilots or snipers. Or maybe they'll enhance someone's dadflex and save a child from incoming danger.
If you say Factorio is fine, then you can't say anything else is any different.
It's like chess, or any other strategic game. There is a big argument that they teach us things.
Just like team sports. It teaches us life skills.
I argue that Factorio teaches more directly applicable life skills to the average person. Most jobs now involve solving some kind of problem using creativity and clicking/typing on a computer.
Yes there are corner cases where it's nice to be a ninja. But most of us click and type on a computer all day solving problems a computer can't. First person shooters can be automated quite easily and have been, playing factorio, chess, etc. Are different. Yes they can still be automated, but it's clearly a higher bar.
Factorio is no more of a problem-solving game than a first-person shooter is. There is a lot going on in a player's mind when playing FPS that may not be obvious, such as planning ahead, quick thinking and anticipating the opponents' movements. Those are also valuable skills that can be applied to many areas of life.
Take Overwatch for example. There are role-based characters that fill a specific function in the game that require thinking, planning, and experience. It is also a team sport that teaches life skills.
I do not see how automation can 'solve' that for you. It is not just purely finding the thing on the screen and clicking on it. They are not just solely twitch-based reactionary games.
As with anything in life, too much chess/Factorio/etc. can also be detrimental.
Balance is key.
Either way, you can't paint a brush on "all FPS" being 'bad'. Just like games in the same vein as Factorio can become very repetitive and require less thinking and more "Just put this block to this block" level of repetitiveness.
If we're talking "average person", I think the benefits are minimal. Some white collar jobs involve creativity but not all. Even jobs that do will not allow you to express that creativity in your early years as you follow whatever instructions your boss gives you.
they both involve thinking and planning and in-game knowledge and mastery to thrive in, but I don't think the benefits are really that comparable.