Except that every OP by default gets their inbox lit up by responses, typically unmoderated, in the order they were received.
So a person lurking casually on Reddit gets the false sense that threads are typically fun and light-hearted, enticing them to post. But the moment they do they become part of the Reddit ingroup, and their inbox gets bombarded with first-post asshat comments. Later, moderators and users downvote the asshats and the backend shuttles them away from all consequent casual lurkers.
It's like pre-digital hazing, except somehow even worse because there's no community bonding (or even community, really). Just unfortunate souls similar the poster below who said their mental health "takes a nose dive" when exposed to the nastier abusive comments/threads. Or even the unlucky lurker who wins the race against the moderators/downvoters of the abusive content. (None of whom are paid, btw. Yay!)