I love learning, and that’s why I’ve never been a great student. In middle school and high school, I spent my free time learning about things that interested me—especially programming. In that time I learned about everything I could because school wasn’t enough. Dynamics and kinematics, geometry, optics, digital signal processing, splines, vector and matrix math, programming language design, lambda calculus, type systems—things no student my age was expected to know or care about.
I got high grades whenever I bothered to put in the busywork, but I had little reason to. Points and grades aren’t worth anything.
Pretending that grades have intrinsic value is toxic to learning and innovative thinking. You get what the teacher explains straight away, and want to move on? Not allowed: you have to go at everyone else’s pace. You want to know more about a related topic? Too bad: you have to follow the curriculum. You want to do projects with real-world value? As if! You have to do homework and memorise information—sadly, the kind of information that might have deep meaning to you if it were framed in another way.
I do think losing points for late assignments is fair, though. It inconveniences the person doing the grading, and in the real world, lateness isn’t tolerable. Besides, if you don’t follow the (meaningless) directions, you should expect (meaningless) punishment.
But here’s the thing: would I have bothered to learn on my own if I hadn’t had the insufficient school system to piss me off? Somehow, I think not.